Australia edition
Canada edition
France edition
Germany edition
India edition
Italy edition
Japan edition
Korea edition
Netherlands edition
Spain edition
Taiwan edition
U.K. edition
U.S. editionIndependent MP Helen Haines, who holds the Victorian seat of Indi, has had both legs amputated after an alleged car attack, the BBC, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, Brisbane Times and WA Today reported. Her husband confirmed the second amputation, according to live coverage and a separate report. Earlier coverage said surgeons were trying to save her remaining leg and her condition was critical. A vigil was held in Wodonga. A man named as Brendan Nugent has been charged with three offences and appeared in court. The BBC reported police charged him over an alleged 'targeted' attack, and live coverage used the word 'intentional'. More details have emerged about Nugent's past, the reports said.
An attack on a sitting MP touches the security of every elected member who holds public meetings and runs open electorate offices. The charges will now move through the courts, which will decide what is established about intent and motive. Until then, public discussion is running ahead of the evidence.
You may see competing explanations online. The charges and the medical facts are confirmed; claims about motive are not, so treat them cautiously.
Some commentary, including a Sydney Morning Herald and The Age analysis, urges caution about linking the attack to political grievances, because the factors that may have led to it are confusing and unproven.
Politicians quoted in a separate column say the job of listening to constituents is becoming more dangerous, yet they say they do not want 24/7 security or to hide away from the public.
Confirmed: the double amputation, the three charges and the court appearance. Not confirmed: a motive, and Haines's longer-term recovery. Watch the next court date and any statement from her family or office.
BBC (police charge man over alleged targeted attack, 10/21) · The Sydney Morning Herald (live updates, 10/21) · The Age (live updates, 10/21) · Brisbane Times (second amputation confirmed, 10/21) · WA Today (analysis on PM's grievances, 10/21)
Helen Haines has both legs amputated after alleged deliberate car attack; man chargedHelen Haines has both legs amputated after alleged deliberate car attack; man charged
Her husband has confirmed a second amputation as the suspect, named as Brendan Nugent, faces three charges.
Independent MP Helen Haines, who represents the north-east Victorian seat of Indi, has had both legs amputated after an alleged deliberate car attack, according to the BBC, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, Brisbane Times and WA Today. Her husband confirmed that she has undergone a second amputation, the outlets reported, after earlier live coverage said surgeons were trying to save her remaining leg. Reports described her condition as critical. A vigil was held in Wodonga, the live coverage reported. A man identified as Brendan Nugent has been charged with three offences over the alleged attack and has appeared in court, the outlets said. The BBC reported that police charged the man over what it described as an alleged 'targeted' attack, while live coverage of the case used the word 'intentional' in describing the allegation. Further reporting said more details have emerged about Nugent's past.
The sequence reported by the outlets runs from the first accounts of one leg lost, with surgeons trying to save the other, to the husband's confirmation of the second amputation. The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age also published an analysis headed 'Caution needed on linking Helen Haines attack to PM's grievances', which dealt with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's remarks on the confusing set of factors that may have led to the incident. The same mastheads carried a column, 'A politician's job is to listen. It's becoming increasingly dangerous to do so', in which Australian politicians said that, despite the obvious challenges, they do not want 24/7 security and do not want to hide away. The reports do not state a motive, and the extent of Haines's recovery has not been confirmed.