Courts · ✓ 4 outlets

A Ninth Circuit panel appears doubtful of the Justice Department’s bid to make California set aside up to 20,000 mail ballots

The New York Times reported on Oct. 25 that a federal appeals court panel seemed disinclined to order California to set aside as many as 20,000 mail-in ballots that the Trump administration claimed were sent to noncitizens. The Hill reported that the Ninth Circuit appeared unlikely to immediately agree to the administration’s bid to segregate the ballots, expressing skepticism at a rare Sunday hearing that a trial judge needs to move quicker. The Los Angeles Times reported that two judges questioned the Justice Department’s lawyer about how the administration’s position squared with the law. Fox News reported that the panel grilled Justice Department lawyers over forcing California to set aside the ballots. None of the reports says the panel has issued a ruling.

The department is asking an appeals court to act before the trial judge has ruled, so the first question is procedural: whether the appeals court can step in at all. If the ballots were set aside, it would change counting rules days before the Nov. 3 election, which is why the panel pressed on the legal basis.

If you are a California voter, nothing in these reports changes how to vote or how your ballot is counted. For everyone else, it is an early test of how far the federal government can go in challenging a state’s voter lists before an election.

The administration’s position, as reported, is that the ballots are tied to suspected noncitizens and should be set aside now. In this view, waiting would let ineligible votes be counted.

The Los Angeles Times reports two judges questioned how the administration’s position squared with the law, and The Hill reports the panel was skeptical of acting before the trial judge. In this view, an emergency order from an appeals court is premature.

Confirmed across outlets: a Sunday Ninth Circuit hearing and judges questioning the government’s bid. Not confirmed: a ruling or its timing. Watch for the panel’s order and for the trial judge’s decision on the underlying request.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 22 · October 26, 2026

Read today’s front page →