Politics · Elections · ✓ 6 outlets · whether any of the voters are noncitizens and the lower court's next ruling are not confirmed

Appeals court declines the administration's request to intervene in California's mail-ballot lawsuit, 2-1

The New York Times reported on Monday, Oct. 26, that a federal appeals court panel, by a 2-1 vote, denied the Trump administration's request that it immediately order California to set aside certain mail ballots. CNN headlined its story that the appeals court rejected the Justice Department's demand to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots, and CBS News headlined that the court dismissed the department's request to force California to set aside the ballots. The Guardian headlined that the court blocked the department's bid to stop California from counting mail-in ballots. Democracy Docket had reported earlier that the department appealed the case before the district court judge had ruled. FinancialJuice reported that the appeals court rejected the administration's request to halt California counting mail ballots from suspected noncitizens. Because the vote was 2-1, one panel member dissented. The ballots at issue belong to voters the department says may be noncitizens.

A 2-1 order that declines to step in leaves the ballots in California's normal count while the lawsuit continues in the lower court. The department's claim is about who is eligible to vote, and the ballots are the most direct way to affect a count before it is certified, which is why the timing so close to the midterm elections matters. The New York Times headline says the court declined to intervene, which is not the same as deciding whether the voters are citizens.

If you vote by mail in California, the ruling means ballots are being counted as usual for now. For readers elsewhere, a similar request to Washington state shows the same argument is being made in more than one place.

The administration's view, as CBS News described the weekend interviews of Attorney General Todd Blanche, is that the Justice Department is entitled to press states on ballots it says come from suspected noncitizens. In this view, the courts should act quickly because voting is already under way.

California officials and the court majority's approach, as the headlines describe it, is that the courts should not skip the lower court and that the ballots should keep being counted. In this view, the department's list of suspected noncitizens is a claim that has not been tested, and acting on it early could cost eligible people their votes.

Confirmed: a 2-1 appeals court order turned away the department's request, and the ballots remain in California's count for now. Not confirmed in the reports cited: whether any of the roughly 20,000 voters are noncitizens, or how the lower court will rule. Watch for the district court's next step and for whether the department goes to the full appeals court.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 23 · October 27, 2026

Read today’s front page →