Law · Courts · ✓ 3 outlets · whether Trump appeals is unconfirmed

Judge dismisses Trump's Epstein-letter defamation suit against Dow Jones and Murdoch with prejudice

U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles in Miami dismissed President Trump's amended defamation lawsuit over a newspaper report on a birthday letter to Jeffrey Epstein on Saturday, Oct. 31. The dismissal is with prejudice, which means Trump cannot file the case again in that court. The defendants include Dow Jones, which publishes the newspaper, and Rupert Murdoch. Gayles wrote that Trump did not plausibly allege actual malice, and that because this was Trump's second attempt, dismissal with prejudice was appropriate. The judge had dismissed the first complaint on April 13 without prejudice and allowed an amended version. The report described a letter bearing Trump's signature in a 2003 album for Epstein's 50th birthday, and Trump has denied writing it. A spokesman for Trump said he "will continue to press forward." No appeal has been confirmed.

Public figures must clear a high bar to win defamation cases: they must show the publisher knew a claim was false or recklessly disregarded the truth. Dismissal with prejudice means the trial court has ruled that the bar was not met even after a second try. The ruling does not decide whether the letter is authentic, which the judge said in April is a question of fact.

The result shows how hard it is for any public figure to win a libel suit over reporting, a protection that also covers ordinary people who comment on officials. It does not settle what the letter says about Trump or Epstein, so expect the dispute to continue in public rather than in court unless an appeal is filed.

Press-freedom advocates say the outcome reflects the First Amendment standard working as designed: a news organization that sought comment and reported on a document should not be punished because its subject disputes it.

Trump's side says the suit raised real questions about a letter it says is fake and that it will keep pressing the case, which can still be taken to an appeals court.

Confirmed: the dismissal is with prejudice and rests on the malice standard. Unconfirmed: whether Trump will appeal and whether the letter is genuine, which this order does not decide. Watch for a notice of appeal, typically due within 30 days of the judgment.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 27 · October 31, 2026 · Evening

Read today’s front page →