Law · Crime · ✓ 2 outlets · ruling expected after the Dec. 10 hearing

Mangione's lawyers press judge to dismiss New York murder charges, arguing double jeopardy after his federal plea

Lawyers for Luigi Mangione have again asked Judge Gregory Carro of Manhattan to dismiss the state murder and weapons charges in the killing of UnitedHealthcare chief executive Brian Thompson, citing double jeopardy. Mangione has pleaded guilty to federal stalking charges and awaits federal sentencing in December. The defense argues that the conduct behind the stalking offense is coterminous with the conduct in the murder case and that there "is and was no other gun." The Manhattan District Attorney's office argues that stalking and murder are separate offenses. The fake-ID charge is not covered by the request. Carro earlier called the argument premature while the federal case was pending and dismissed the state terrorism count in September. The next hearing is Dec. 10, and the state trial is delayed indefinitely.

Double jeopardy bars a second trial for the same offense, but federal and state governments are separate sovereigns, and courts have generally let both prosecute. The defense is arguing that the federal plea already covers the conduct at issue and that the state case is a second punishment for it. If the judge agrees, the state murder charge could end before trial.

For most readers this is a test of how far double jeopardy protects someone prosecuted by two governments, a rule that applies to anyone, not only high-profile defendants. The outcome will shape how the case proceeds in the new year.

The defense says the same facts are being prosecuted twice, that the earlier federal reasoning supports its view, and that the Constitution forbids a second round of punishment for the same conduct.

Prosecutors say stalking and murder are distinct crimes with different elements, that a federal sentence is not yet imposed, and that New York has its own interest in prosecuting a killing that happened on a Manhattan street.

Confirmed: the motion is pending, the next hearing is Dec. 10, and the trial is delayed. Not confirmed: how the judge will rule, or when. The decision, whenever it comes, can be appealed.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 27 · October 31, 2026 · Evening

Read today’s front page →