Judge dismisses Trump's revised $10 billion defamation suit over a report on an Epstein birthday letter, with prejudice
A federal judge in Miami, Darrin Gayles, dismissed President Trump's revised $10 billion defamation suit on Saturday, Oct. 31. The suit targeted a newspaper's reporting on a birthday letter attributed to Trump and sent to Jeffrey Epstein, and it named publisher Rupert Murdoch as a defendant. The judge dismissed it with prejudice, ruling that the president did not prove the defendants made defamatory statements with actual malice, the legal standard for a public figure. He wrote that Trump was “grasping at straws.” An earlier version of the suit was dismissed in April, and Trump had said he would refile.
Public figures must show that a statement was false and that the publisher knew it was false or recklessly ignored the truth. A dismissal with prejudice means the same claims cannot be filed again in that court, leaving appeal as the only path. The ruling reinforces how hard it is for a public figure to win such a case.
The decision matters for anyone who reads or publishes news: it shows courts still give wide room to reporting on public figures. It does not settle whether the letter is genuine, because the ruling turned on the legal standard rather than on the letter itself.
Trump's side has said the story was false and defamatory and that the suit was a way to hold a major outlet to account. His allies see the revised filing as an effort to cure the defects the court found the first time.
Press-freedom advocates and the defendants say the ruling confirms the suit lacked evidence of malice and was an attempt to pressure a news organization. They note the judge's blunt language and the fact that this was a second dismissal.
Confirmed: dismissal with prejudice on Saturday and a ruling that actual malice was not shown. Not confirmed: whether Trump appeals. A notice of appeal would be the next step to watch.
DailyDrop U.S. No. 28 · November 1, 2026 · Evening