Law · ✓ 3 outlets

Supreme Court takes up a Catholic challenge to Colorado's universal pre-K rules on enrolling LGBTQ families

The Supreme Court is set to hear St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy this week, a challenge to a Colorado rule tied to its universal preschool program. Colorado requires participating schools to offer an equal opportunity to enroll regardless of sexual orientation. The Archdiocese of Denver, which runs 34 Catholic preschools, wants to be able to turn away LGBTQ families while taking state funds. Two parishes and two parents joined the suit. The archdiocese lost in federal district court and the 10th Circuit. The justices may consider narrowing a 1990 precedent, Employment Division v. Smith. A decision is likely by next summer.

The case asks whether a state can attach nondiscrimination conditions to money it gives to religious institutions. A ruling for the archdiocese would reach beyond preschool to other public programs that fund religious groups, and one for Colorado would leave the conditions in place.

If you use or fund state-supported child care or schools, the outcome could change what rules those programs can enforce. For now nothing changes in Colorado's program.

The archdiocese and its lawyers argue that excluding Catholic preschools over their beliefs is religious discrimination, since the families they serve want a Catholic education.

Colorado and civil rights groups argue the program is inclusive, that Catholic preschools remain welcome to take part, and that public money should not fund turning children away.

Confirmed: the case, the parties and the questions before the court. Unconfirmed: how the justices will rule, which will not be known until next summer. Watch the argument for signs on Employment Division v. Smith.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 29 · November 2, 2026

Read today’s front page →