Law · Supreme Court · ✓ 3 outlets · how the justices lean; when a ruling comes

Supreme Court hears Catholic parish's challenge to Colorado's universal preschool rules

The Supreme Court heard oral argument Tuesday, November 3, in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, No. 25-581. The case asks whether Colorado can exclude a Catholic parish's preschool from its universal preschool program because the school will not follow the program's nondiscrimination rules, which include admitting children of same-sex couples. The parish says the requirement conflicts with its religious beliefs and invokes the First Amendment's free exercise clause. The Tenth Circuit ruled for Colorado, finding the rules neutral and applied to every preschool, and relied on Employment Division v. Smith. The Court agreed to hear the case on April 20. The solicitor general has urged the justices to rule for the parish. No ruling has been issued.

The case could change how far religious organizations that take public money can be required to follow civil-rights rules. A ruling for the parish would limit what states can require of faith-based providers in programs they fund, and a ruling for Colorado would keep the general rule that neutral laws apply to everyone. The effects would reach beyond preschools, to child care, schools, and social services that receive state funds.

If you use Colorado's preschool program or a similar state-funded program elsewhere, nothing changes today; the program's rules stay in place until the Court rules. If you work for a religious organization that receives public funds, the eventual decision may change what your state can require.

The parish and its supporters argue that excluding a religious school from a public benefit because of its beliefs penalizes religious exercise, and that Colorado can fund preschool without forcing a church to violate its teaching. The administration agrees.

Colorado and groups that defend its rule argue that a state may set the same conditions for every provider that takes public money, and that children of same-sex couples should not be turned away from a publicly funded program. They say a religious exemption would open the door to other exceptions.

Confirmed: argument was held today and the Court has not ruled. Not confirmed: how the justices lean. Watch for a decision in the coming months.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 30 · November 3, 2026 · Evening

Read today’s front page →