Politics · Courts and the vote · ✓ 4 outlets · whether the department pursues its appeal and criminal cases

Supreme Court rejects the Justice Department's emergency request to make California set aside 20,000 mail ballots

The Supreme Court on Monday rejected a Justice Department emergency application asking it to order California to set aside about 20,000 mail ballots. The department says the ballots belong to voters who are likely noncitizens. Lawyers for the department filed the application earlier Monday, and the Court acted within hours. A federal judge in Los Angeles had rejected the request, and the Ninth Circuit court of appeals denied it 2-1 on Friday. A separate federal judge ruled that the administration cannot pressure states to segregate such votes. California counts mail ballots that arrive up to seven days after Election Day. No court has accepted the department's figure, and California officials dispute it.

An emergency application skips the normal appeals timetable, so the denial ends the effort to change California's count before the election. It also means ballots from voters on the department's list will be counted like all others, and any challenge to an individual voter's eligibility must go through ordinary legal channels.

If you are a California voter, your mail ballot is counted under the state's normal rules, including if it arrives up to a week after Election Day. Voters elsewhere should expect courts to resist last-minute changes to how ballots are handled.

The administration argues that noncitizens on voter rolls threaten election integrity and that federal law lets it demand safeguards before ballots are counted. It says the 20,000 names come from its review of voter data.

California officials and the lower courts say federal law does not let the government order states to halt or segregate ballots, and a judge warned that doing so would wreak havoc. They say the list has not been shown to be accurate.

Confirmed: the Court denied the request Monday and California's count proceeds. Not confirmed: the accuracy of the 20,000 figure, which no court has accepted, and what the department will do next. Watch for its appeal in the lower courts and criminal cases against individual voters, and for any new filing before California's polls close at 11 p.m. Eastern.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 30 · November 3, 2026

Read today’s front page →