Law · ✓ 2 outlets

Justice Sotomayor Calls This a “Rough Patch” for the Rule of Law and Hopes the Court Reverses Some Rulings

Justice Sonia Sotomayor of the Supreme Court was reported over the weekend describing the United States as in a rough patch for the rule of law. In remarks reported separately, she said she hopes the Supreme Court will reverse some of its own rulings, and one account quotes her saying crazy things. The remarks were published on Saturday, Nov. 7, and Sunday, Nov. 8.

Justices rarely comment on their colleagues' rulings or call for them to be overturned, so public remarks like these get attention. The Supreme Court can reverse its earlier decisions, but that takes a later case and enough votes. The rule of law means that governments and officials are bound by law and court rulings.

If you follow legal questions that affect daily life, such as immigration, voting or regulation, the idea that precedent can change helps explain why court cases are watched so closely. Her remarks are one justice's view, not a ruling.

Admirers see a justice speaking plainly about threats to legal norms and about decisions she thinks were wrong.

Critics of public remarks by justices say commenting on pending or past cases and urging reversal can weaken the Court's image as impartial.

Confirmed: Sotomayor made the remarks as quoted in two reports. Not confirmed: the full context, such as the audience and which rulings she meant. Watch for the full transcript or recording.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 35 · November 8, 2026

Read today’s front page →