Proposition 40 trails in California’s unofficial count; news organizations projected its defeat Monday evening, six days after Election Day. The measure would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on most of the wealth, including ownership stakes in companies, of California residents worth more than billion. Backers wanted the revenue to go mostly to health care. Latest tallies put the no vote at about 53%, and early returns on Nov. 4 had it near 56%; the totals differ slightly between counts. The campaign was the most expensive ballot campaign in California history, and opponents raised far more than supporters. Politicians, a teachers union and other groups opposed the measure, and it divided Democrats. County officials are still counting ballots and have not certified the result. Propositions 41 and 42, written to undercut the tax, were also on the ballot.
A wealth tax taxes what people own rather than what they earn, so it would have required valuing private company stakes year after year in the nation’s largest state. The vote tested whether such a tax can win at the ballot box, and the result is the starting point for any next attempt, in California or elsewhere.
Unless you hold more than billion, nothing changes in what you owe. If you work in health care funding or tech, the loss means the proposed health-care money will not arrive, and the debate over how to fund it continues. If you live in California, expect counties to finish counting and certify in the coming weeks.
Supporters argued that the revenue was needed for health care and that the very wealthy should contribute more to pay for it.
Opponents argued that a tax on unrealized wealth would be hard to administer, that billionaires could move away, and that squeezing the ultra-rich would hurt California’s economy.
Confirmed: news organizations’ projections of defeat, the measure trailing in the unofficial count, a one-time 5% rate on most of the wealth of residents over billion, and record campaign spending. Not confirmed: the final margin, spending totals that vary by tally, and the results for Props. 41 and 42. Watch county certification and whether sponsors in other states revive a wealth tax.
New York Times (Prop. 40 rejected, Nov. 9) · NBC News (Prop. 40 projected to fail, Nov. 9) · CBS News (wealth tax rejected, Nov. 9) · NPR (billionaire tax defeated, Nov. 9) · The Guardian (most expensive campaign, Nov. 9)
Prop. 40, California’s Billionaire Wealth Tax, Trails in the Unofficial Count; the Result Is Not Yet Certified
Politics · California Ballot✓ 5 outlets · the count is unofficial and uncertified; results for Props. 41 and 42 and the exact margin and spending totals are unconfirmed
Prop. 40, California’s Billionaire Wealth Tax, Trails in the Unofficial Count; the Result Is Not Yet Certified
The one-time 5% tax on billionaires’ wealth is trailing in the unofficial count after the most expensive ballot campaign in state history, with Democrats split over it.
In California’s unofficial count, Proposition 40 is trailing. The ballot measure would have charged residents worth more than $1 billion a one-time 5% tax on most of their wealth, including their ownership stakes in companies. News organizations projected its defeat Monday evening, six days after Election Day, while counties were still counting ballots; the result is not certified. A wealth tax is charged on what a person owns, such as shares, private companies and property, rather than on income earned in a year. The money was meant to go mostly to health care. In dollars, 5% of a $10 billion fortune is $500 million, though the measure reached most, not all, of a person’s wealth, so the actual bill would have been somewhat smaller. The campaign was the most expensive ballot campaign in state history, with Silicon Valley donors supplying much of the money. Opponents were far better funded than supporters, and reported spending totals vary by tally. The fight also split Democrats in California and across the country.
Opponents, who included politicians, a teachers union and other powerful groups, argued that squeezing California’s ultra-rich would hurt the state’s economy. The latest tallies put the no vote at about 53%, though the totals differ slightly from one count to the next, and early returns on Nov. 4 had it nearer 56% before the gap narrowed as more ballots were counted. Those figures are unofficial: a result becomes final only when county elections officials finish counting and certify it, and that has not happened. Two companion measures, Propositions 41 and 42, were written to undercut the tax, and final results for them were not available. Until certification, the margin can still move a little, but the projection of a loss is not in doubt in the tallies now public.
Unfold the story and DailyDrop's take
President Trump told reporters Monday that Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang told him he had no idea that Alice Huang was a spy. Trump said he believes Huang’s account and does not recall a briefing that warned him about the relationship. Trump also said the FBI is looking into the matter and did not say what it is examining. Nvidia’s board opened an independent investigation Sunday, the day Huang wrote employees that he had been unfaithful to his wife. The board said it has no reason to believe company secrets or national security were compromised. China’s government called the spying allegation unsubstantiated. Sen. Chris Coons said he is pushing to investigate whether national security was compromised. Three House committee chairmen have asked Huang for a closed-door briefing on Nov. 18. The claim that Alice Huang worked for Chinese intelligence rests on unnamed U.S. officials.
Nvidia makes the chips behind most advanced artificial intelligence, and Washington treats who gets them as a national security question. When the head of that company is linked to someone officials suspect of working for Beijing, a private matter becomes a question about safeguards, export rules and what the government knew. The president’s statement shifts attention from the board to the White House.
If you own Nvidia directly or through an index fund, the stock has swung with each development, and the earnings report the day before the Nov. 18 briefing is the next hard data. If you work in tech or follow chip export rules, expect more questions from Congress about who can buy advanced chips.
Huang’s defenders, including the president, say the allegation rests on unnamed officials, Nvidia denies any disclosure of sensitive information, and an affair is a personal failing that does not by itself show a security breach.
Lawmakers pressing for answers, including some Democrats and the House chairmen, say a company this central to AI cannot be exposed to foreign intelligence without scrutiny, and they want to know why a reported earlier briefing led to no action.
Confirmed: Trump’s statement that Huang denied knowing, China’s denial, the board’s investigation, Coons’s call and the Nov. 18 briefing request. Not confirmed: that Alice Huang worked for Chinese intelligence, what the FBI is examining, and the earlier-briefing claim. Watch Nvidia’s earnings and whether Huang agrees to brief Congress.
CNBC (Trump says Huang denied knowing, Nov. 9) · CBS News (Trump on Huang, Nov. 9) · New York Times (Trump believes Huang, Nov. 9) · The Hill (Coons demands probe, Nov. 9)
Trump Says Nvidia’s Jensen Huang Told Him He Had “No Idea” the Woman Was a Spy; China Calls the Allegation Unsubstantiated
Technology · Politics✓ 4 outlets · what the FBI is examining, and whether the spy allegation is true, are unconfirmed
Trump Says Nvidia’s Jensen Huang Told Him He Had “No Idea” the Woman Was a Spy; China Calls the Allegation Unsubstantiated
President Trump said Monday that Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang told him he had “no idea” that Alice Huang, the executive he has acknowledged an affair with, was a spy. Trump said he believes Huang’s account and that he does not recall receiving a briefing that warned him about the relationship. He also said the FBI is looking into the matter, without saying what it is examining or when that began. Alice Huang, who is not related to Jensen Huang, is an executive at Megaspeed, a cloud-computing company. The claim that she worked for Chinese intelligence comes from unnamed U.S. officials, and no public finding or criminal charge has been reported. Earlier reporting, also citing unnamed officials, said Trump was briefed on the relationship about a year ago; no named official has confirmed that. Nvidia’s board opened an independent investigation Sunday, the same day Huang sent employees a letter admitting he had been unfaithful to his wife. The board said it has no reason to believe the company’s secrets or national security were compromised, and Huang said he supports the investigation and will cooperate fully. China’s government said the spying allegation is unsubstantiated. In Washington, Sen. Chris Coons, a Delaware Democrat, said he is pushing to investigate whether national security was compromised, and three House committee chairmen have asked Huang for a closed-door briefing on Nov. 18, the day after Nvidia reports third-quarter results. Nvidia shares fell sharply Monday, roughly 4% to 5% in the reports, which differ by the hour. Whether Huang will attend the briefing has not been disclosed.
Unfold the story and DailyDrop's take