Appeals court says Justice Department demand for reporters’ LinkedIn records is too broad
On Tuesday, November 10, a three-judge panel of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a Justice Department demand for journalists’ LinkedIn records was too broad. The opinion was written by Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson and joined by Judges Andrew Wynn and Nicole Berner. The government had sought metadata covering 18 months of the reporters’ activity, including the identities of people they communicated with, but not the messages themselves. The demand arose in a leak investigation. An accompanying order barred LinkedIn from notifying its users for a year, and the panel found that order too broad as well. The court denied LinkedIn’s request to quash the disclosure order entirely, rejected the government’s argument that LinkedIn had shown no injury, and returned the case to the district court to narrow the demand. The case is No. 26-4303.
Reporters’ communication records can reveal who their confidential sources are even when no message text is handed over. A ruling that such demands must be tailored raises the bar for prosecutors who want sweeping records from technology companies. It also shows that the company that holds the data can contest the demand, instead of leaving reporters to learn about it later.
If you rely on a journalist or a news tip line, the practical protection is the court’s requirement that demands be narrow, though it covers only the Fourth Circuit states for now. Anyone who talks to reporters on a work platform should know that records of who they contacted can be sought.
Press-freedom advocates read the decision as an important limit: records about who reporters talk to are close to the heart of source protection, and the court recognized that a broad request could expose unrelated sources.
The government’s position, as described in the proceedings, is that criminal investigators need the records for national security and leak cases and that a platform has no standing to impose limits. The court partly agreed, by not canceling the order and by sending it back for narrowing.
Confirmed: a unanimous panel found the demand and the secrecy order too broad and returned the case for narrowing. Not confirmed: how narrow the new order will be, and whether the Justice Department appeals. Early coverage differs on whether the ruling ‘blocked’ or ‘limited’ the demand; ‘limited and sent back’ is the accurate description. Watch the lower court’s next order.
DailyDrop U.S. No. 38 · November 11, 2026