Russia's Foreign Ministry said the heads of state of Russia, China and the United States adopted a declaration on peace after their trilateral meeting in Shenzhen, and it posted a text it described as the full declaration. Chinese and Russian officials said the three sides agreed on United Nations reforms, on boosting fuel supplies and on a dialogue about nuclear weapons. The White House has said little in the hours since the meeting. President Trump is set to give a news conference on the trip, according to one report. A report says a reporter was barred from the talks after asking about Nvidia. The United States has not publicly confirmed the terms described by Moscow and Beijing.
A joint declaration among three nuclear-armed powers that each hold a veto on the U.N. Security Council would matter for arms control, the war in Ukraine and sanctions, but only if its terms bind the governments that signed it. At the moment one side's description is all that is public, which leaves the content and the strength of any commitment open. How the United States characterizes the text will show whether the three agree on what they signed.
Oil and gas prices, tariffs and the outlook for the Ukraine war can move on signals from a meeting like this, so expect it to stay in the news into Friday. Nothing in the reporting requires any action from you.
One reading is that the declaration and the show of three leaders at one table are themselves the result: they signal that the three powers intend to coordinate on global questions, which is how Moscow and Beijing have framed it.
A second reading is that a declaration described only by two of the three governments proves little, that one earlier report of little Russian and Chinese interest in a nuclear deal makes the nuclear dialogue thin, and that the White House's silence suggests the American account may differ.
Confirmed: the three leaders met, Russia's ministry says a declaration on peace was adopted, and Chinese and Russian officials describe agreement on U.N. reforms, fuel supplies and nuclear dialogue. Not confirmed: the American reading of those terms or any binding commitment. Watch Trump's news conference for the White House version.
AP News (China and Russia describe agreements, Nov. 19) · Washington Post (White House largely mum, Nov. 19) · The Hill (peace declaration issued, Nov. 19) · New York Times (reporter barred from talks, Nov. 19)
China and Russia Say the Three Leaders Agreed on United Nations Reforms, Fuel Supplies and Nuclear Dialogue; the White House Has Said LittleChina and Russia Say the Three Leaders Agreed on United Nations Reforms, Fuel Supplies and Nuclear Dialogue; the White House Has Said Little
Moscow and Beijing describe a four-point peace declaration from the Shenzhen talks; Washington has not yet given its own account.
Hours after the first three-way meeting of the leaders of the United States, China and Russia, Beijing and Moscow have described what came out of it. Russia's Foreign Ministry said the three heads of state adopted a joint declaration on peace at the end of the Shenzhen talks, and it posted a text it described as the full declaration. Chinese and Russian officials said the three sides agreed on reforms to the United Nations, on boosting fuel supplies and on a dialogue about nuclear weapons, and one report says the four-point text also touches the International Criminal Court. Those descriptions come from the Chinese and Russian side. The United States has not publicly confirmed the terms, and the declaration's wording has not been checked against an American account.
The White House was largely silent in the hours after the trilateral meeting. President Trump is set to give a news conference on the trip, according to one report, so the American version of what was agreed is still to come. A report says a reporter was barred from the talks after asking about Nvidia. Before the meeting, one report said Moscow and Beijing had shown little interest in the three-way nuclear deal Trump wanted, which makes the wording of any nuclear dialogue the main thing to read closely. The open questions are what the declaration commits each government to, whether Washington describes it the same way, and what a dialogue on nuclear weapons means in practice.