Justice · ✓ 2 outlets

South Carolina's Parole Board Unanimously Denies Susan Smith Release for a Second Time, 32 Years After She Drowned Her Two Sons, Reports Say

South Carolina's parole board unanimously denied parole to Susan Smith on Thursday, her second denial. She drowned her two young sons, Michael and Alex, in a lake in 1994, and it has been 32 years. Reports say the seven-member board voted without discussion and that Smith appeared by video, asked for release and said she had changed. The boys' father, David Smith, urged the board to deny parole and called release an injustice. Her attorney said mental health was central to the case. Reports say the board received 10,845 statements opposing release and that her next hearing will be in 2028.

Parole boards decide whether a person serving a sentence with a chance of release may leave early, and in South Carolina a grant requires a two-thirds vote of members present. A unanimous denial means no member voted for release, and it resets the clock to the next hearing.

Victims' families often attend or send statements at hearings like this one; if you are ever affected by a case, parole boards accept written input. The decision also shows that serving 30 years does not guarantee release.

Supporters of the denial, including the boys' father and thousands who sent statements, say the crime was deliberate and that release would be unjust. On this view the board reached the only fitting result.

Smith's attorney argued that mental health was central to what happened and that she has changed after decades in prison. On this view the parole system exists to weigh that kind of change.

Confirmed: the board denied parole unanimously. Not confirmed: the board's reasons, because reports say it gave no detailed explanation. Today, nothing further is scheduled; the next hearing is reported for 2028.

DailyDrop U.S. No. 47 · November 20, 2026

Read today’s front page →