Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that on the 23rd the Seoul High Court, at the sentencing hearing in the appellate trial of the ‘Myung Tae-kyun poll proxy-payment allegations’ case, acquitted Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon. Newsis reported that the first trial had imposed a fine of 10 million won and that Oh’s side appealed on the day of sentencing. Kyunghyang Shinmun’s ‘Verdict Close-up’ reported that the second trial, unlike the first, did not accept Myung Tae-kyun’s statement that ‘he received a poll commission from Mayor Oh and was paid the cost by supporter Kim Han-jung.’ Korea Economic Daily covered how Myung’s statement “Oh Se-hoon doesn’t know” aroused the court’s doubt, and Yonhap reported that the issue in the Supreme Court appeal could be corroborating evidence for Myung’s statement. Yonhap reported that Oh raised ‘party unity’ the day after his acquittal, and Yonhap and Chosun Ilbo reported that independent lawmaker Han Dong-hoon said on the 25th, “He is someone we should go with for the conservative camp’s victory.” Hankyoreh reported that Cho Kuk called the ruling a “counterattack of judicial politics,” and Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that the Democratic Party leadership raised a parliamentary investigation of Chief Justice Cho Hee-de on the 25th.
The Political Funds Act strips an elected official of office once a fine of 1 million won or more is finalized, so the appellate result bore directly on whether Oh keeps the mayor’s seat. With the first trial finding guilt and the second finding innocence, the case leaves a Supreme Court ruling to come, and the credibility of Myung’s statement, the point at issue, may be examined in the Supreme Court appeal as well. As Oh’s legal risk eased, the line-up of conservative presidential contenders and the ruling camp’s response to the judiciary both moved at once.
If you care about whether Oh keeps the mayor’s office and what the political calendar looks like afterward, it is worth checking whether and when prosecutors appeal to the Supreme Court. Whether the National Assembly’s debate over the judiciary leads to a parliamentary investigation could change this week’s Assembly schedule.
This view reads the ruling as a political signal from the judiciary. Cho Kuk’s remark, reported by Hankyoreh, framed the ruling as a “counterattack of judicial politics,” and Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that along this line the Democratic Party leadership raised a parliamentary investigation of Chief Justice Cho Hee-de. In this view, the issue is less the ruling itself than the means of checking the judiciary.
This view holds that the acquittal has changed the conservative camp’s alignment. Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that assessments have emerged that Oh has cemented his standing as a presidential contender and that a three-way race has formed with party leader Jang Dong-hyuk and lawmaker Han Dong-hoon. Han said “I have never let go of his hand” and that they should go together, and Yonhap reported that Oh raised ‘party unity.’ In this view, the ruling feeds into the contest for leadership within the party.
What is confirmed is the Seoul High Court’s acquittal on the 23rd, Oh’s mention of ‘party unity,’ and lawmaker Han Dong-hoon’s remarks on the 25th. What is not confirmed is whether prosecutors will appeal to the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court’s review schedule, and how and when the Democratic Party would pursue a parliamentary investigation. Today it is worth watching how the dispute over Chief Justice Cho Hee-de continues in the closing stretch of the National Assembly audit.
Yonhap (party unity remark and Supreme Court appeal issue, 10/25) · Kyunghyang Shinmun (People Power Party three-way race and Verdict Close-up, 10/25) · Korea Economic Daily (Myung Tae-kyun statement, 10/25) · Chosun Ilbo (Han Dong-hoon remarks, 10/25) · Hankyoreh (Cho Kuk remarks, 10/25) · Newsis (first-trial ruling, 7/23)
After Oh Se-hoon’s acquittal on appeal, Han Dong-hoon says “we should go together”… Democratic Party raises parliamentary investigation of Chief Justice Cho Hee-de
Yonhap reported that Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon raised ‘party unity’ the day after his acquittal, and that independent lawmaker Han Dong-hoon said on the 25th, “He is someone we should go with for the conservative camp’s victory.”
Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that on the 23rd the Seoul High Court acquitted Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon, indicted for violating the Political Funds Act, in the appellate trial of the case over the alleged proxy payment of Myung Tae-kyun’s poll fees. Newsis reported that the first trial had imposed a fine of 10 million won and that Oh’s side appealed on the day of sentencing. According to Kyunghyang Shinmun’s ‘Verdict Close-up’, the second trial, unlike the first, did not accept the statement of political broker Myung Tae-kyun that ‘he received a poll commission from Mayor Oh and was paid the cost by supporter Kim Han-jung.’ Korea Economic Daily looked at how Myung’s statement “Oh Se-hoon doesn’t know” aroused the court’s doubt, and Yonhap reported that the issue in the Supreme Court appeal of this case, in which guilt and innocence were reversed between the first and second trials, could be corroborating evidence for Myung’s statement.
Yonhap reported that Mayor Oh raised ‘party unity’ on the 25th, the day after his acquittal. Independent lawmaker Han Dong-hoon described Oh on the 25th as “a very reasonable person,” saying he is “someone we should go with for the conservative camp’s victory” and “I have never let go of his hand,” Yonhap and Chosun Ilbo reported. Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that, with assessments emerging that the acquittal has cemented Oh’s standing as a presidential contender, the contest for leadership of the conservative camp has become a three-way race among Oh, party leader Jang Dong-hyuk, who the same day became the longest-serving leader since the founding of the People Power Party, and Han Dong-hoon. Hankyoreh reported that Cho Kuk criticized the Democratic Party, calling the ruling a “counterattack of judicial politics.” Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that Oh’s acquittal intensified impeachment calls against Chief Justice Cho Hee-de, that the Democratic Party leadership raised a parliamentary investigation on the 25th, and that party leader Kim Min-seok said it would proceed “step by step, including a parliamentary investigation.”