About $6.3 billion worth of crypto left Binance at the end of last month. The theft took place from wallets on 10 blockchains, and most of it moved within about 20 minutes. Binance has frozen about $3 billion worth and said the company, not users, would bear the loss. Withdrawals resumed in stages from 3 p.m. Korea time on the 1st. By 12:30 a.m. on the 2nd, $4.649 billion in withdrawals and .01 billion in deposits had been processed, for a net outflow of about $3.64 billion, which is 2.1% of the 71 billion in assets under management as of Oct. 28. Analytics firm TRM assessed with high confidence that the North Korean group TraderTraitor was responsible, and the FBI named the group as behind it in its statement on the 31st. On the 2nd the Financial Services Commission summoned domestic crypto exchanges and urged them to raise the share held in cold wallets, check constantly, report quickly and set aside additional reserves.
An exchange holds users’ crypto on their behalf, so after a large theft users may pull out their assets right away. That the net outflow right after withdrawals resumed exceeded 2% of assets under management shows in numbers that a promise of compensation alone does not bring trust back immediately. Korean exchanges have the same structure, so the Commission moved to check cold wallets and reserves first.
Users who keep assets at a domestic exchange can check how that exchange discloses its cold wallet share and reserves. Even if you have not signed up with Binance, if crypto prices swing, the value of coins you hold may move too. This incident could lead to tighter security checks at domestic exchanges.
Some see Binance’s pledge of full compensation and its roughly $3 billion frozen as the capacity to cover the damage. In this view the rush of withdrawals is temporary anxiety, and outflows ease once the compensation plan is carried out.
Others see the net outflow, which exceeded 2% of assets under management right after withdrawals resumed, as a sign that damage to trust has already begun. In this view the structure that leans only on an exchange’s own capacity to compensate should be reviewed, and reserve and cold wallet standards should be made stricter in Korea too.
What is confirmed is the $6.3 billion theft, the net outflow figures after withdrawals resumed, and the Commission’s request. What is not confirmed is how the hack happened and how much of the stolen assets will be recovered. The naming of a North Korean group is the judgment of the analytics firm and the FBI, and Binance has said it is working with investigators to identify the perpetrators. Today, watch whether the net outflow stops and what domestic exchanges announce on reserves.
Yonhap (net outflow tally, 11/2) · Dong-A Ilbo (details of Commission summons, 11/2) · Chosun Ilbo (outflow after withdrawals resumed, 11/2) · Korea Economic Daily (capacity to cover, 11/2) · AP (analytics firm assessment, 10/30)
Finance · Crypto✓ 5 outlets · how the hack happened and how much of the stolen assets will be recovered unconfirmed
Binance net outflow nears 5 trillion won after withdrawals reopen… FSC tells Korean exchanges to add reserves
Once withdrawals reopened, users pulled out their assets, and the Financial Services Commission summoned domestic crypto exchanges on the 2nd.
From Binance, the world’s largest crypto exchange, $6.3 billion, about 8.4 trillion won, drained out at the end of last month, and when withdrawals reopened, users began pulling out their money. The theft took place from wallets on 10 blockchains, and most of it moved within about 20 minutes. Binance has frozen about $3 billion worth and said the company, not users, would bear the loss. It says it found no evidence that a private key had leaked. Withdrawals resumed in stages from 3 p.m. Korea time on the 1st, and by 12:30 a.m. on the 2nd, $4.649 billion in withdrawals and $1.01 billion in deposits had been processed. The net outflow, money out minus money in, was about $3.64 billion, roughly 4.85 trillion won, which is 2.1% of the $171 billion in assets under management as of Oct. 28. A later tally put it as high as the 6 trillion won range, so the figure differs depending on when it is counted.
The North Korean hacking group ‘TraderTraitor’ has been named as the culprit. Blockchain analytics firm TRM said it assesses this “with high confidence,” Chainalysis also said the group is likely responsible, and the US Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) named the group in a statement on the 31st of last month. Binance has said it is working with investigators to identify the perpetrators. An early inquiry raised the possibility that a breach of an engineer’s laptop was the starting point, but how it happened has not been confirmed. In Korea, the Financial Services Commission (FSC) on the 2nd urgently summoned won-market exchanges and coin-market exchanges, including Upbit, Bithumb, Coinone, DigitalX and Gopax, and urged them to raise the share held in cold wallets, check deposits and withdrawals at all times and secure response staff, report hacking attempts promptly, and set aside additional reserves. A cold wallet is an offline wallet kept disconnected from the internet, and reserves are money set aside so that users can be compensated in the event of an incident. The FSC is also considering ways to block withdrawals quickly when a hack is suspected.
Unfold the story and DailyDrop’s take
On June 2, an Excel file titled ‘Air Force One passenger list’ was posted to a paid malware-scanning site. The file held data on 168 Air Force One passengers, including the birth dates and passport numbers of President Lee Jae-myung and the president’s spouse. Data on senior officials such as Prime Minister Han Seong-sook (then Minister of SMEs and Startups) and National Security Office chief Wi Sung-lac, as well as security guards and reporters who cover the president, was also included. It is the list from the June tour of Europe. The file was exposed for about five months and became known on the 2nd. Cheong Wa Dae said it took response measures after becoming aware in advance and that the Foreign Ministry and others plan further measures. The Foreign Ministry takes the matter seriously and is investigating how it happened. The route of the leak has not been confirmed.
Passport numbers and birth dates are used for airline bookings, immigration documents and identity checks, so once spread they are hard to change. The data of the president’s party also touches on security and movements. When the government learned of the exposure and what it did is the key to settling responsibility.
A passport number, used together with a name and birth date, can be abused in identity verification. Uploading work files to an outside site for a security check can happen to anyone, so before uploading, check whether that site shares files with other users.
Cheong Wa Dae stresses that it took response measures after learning of the exposure and that the Foreign Ministry and others will take further steps. In this view, since the possibility of personal data exposure is confirmed, finishing the inquiry into how it happened comes first.
Some question the explanation that it responded after being aware in advance. In this view, explaining why the file remained for five months and when the government learned of it should come first.
What is confirmed is the June 2 posting of the file, the inclusion of 168 people’s data, about five months of exposure, and Cheong Wa Dae’s explanation that it responded after being aware in advance. What is not confirmed is the route of the leak, whether the file was actually downloaded, and when the government first learned of it. The Foreign Ministry’s findings and whether an investigation begins are worth watching.
Yonhap (presidential passport numbers exposed, 11/2) · Dong-A Ilbo (168 people’s data leaked, 11/2) · Korea Economic Daily (passenger list leaked, 11/2) · Kyunghyang Shinmun (Cheong Wa Dae response, 11/2)
Politics · Security✓ 4 outlets · route of the leak and whether the file was actually downloaded unconfirmed
Passport numbers of presidential couple among data of 168 ‘Air Force One passengers’ left exposed on malware-scanning site for five months… Cheong Wa Dae: “Aware in advance, we responded”
It became known on the 2nd that the personal data of 168 Air Force One passengers, including the presidential couple, had been exposed for about five months on a paid malware-scanning website. On June 2, an Excel file titled ‘Air Force One passenger list’ was posted, containing the birth dates and passport numbers of President Lee Jae-myung and the president’s spouse, as well as data on senior officials such as Prime Minister Han Seong-sook (then Minister of SMEs and Startups) and National Security Office chief Wi Sung-lac, security guards and reporters who cover the president. It is the list from the June tour of Europe. Cheong Wa Dae said, “We took response measures after becoming aware of the content of the report in advance, and the Foreign Ministry and others plan further measures.” The Foreign Ministry takes the matter seriously and is investigating how it happened. It has not been settled whether hacking was the cause or whether internal staff uploaded the file directly in the course of a security check of the tour documents. Whether the file was downloaded during the exposure period, and when the government first learned of it, have also not yet been disclosed.
Unfold the story and DailyDrop’s take