The leaders of the United States, China and Russia held their first three-way talks on the 19th in Shenzhen, China. The talks ended after about 1 hour 30 minutes. Russia’s Foreign Ministry released the full text of a peace declaration by the three leaders. The declaration contains wording that nuclear war cannot be won and the holding of dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing nuclear proliferation. China and Russia said they also agreed with the United States on UN reform and on expanding fuel supplies. President Xi was reported to have called the talks positive and constructive. President Trump said AI safety was discussed with Xi in a limited way.
That two countries holding most of the world’s nuclear forces and the world’s two largest economies sat at one table is in itself a signal of a shift in the diplomatic landscape. The war in Ukraine, energy supplies and nuclear control are all at stake at once, so the account of any one country alone makes it hard to gauge the weight of the agreement.
Energy prices, exchange rates and Korean export sectors such as defense and semiconductors are sensitive to U.S.-China relations and the direction of the war in Ukraine. If expanded fuel supplies are a real agreement, oil price trends could also be affected, so later announcements are worth watching.
Those with a positive view see meaning in the fact that the first three-way talks were held and that dialogue to reduce nuclear risks was promised. The argument is that having a channel for dialogue lowers the risk of clashes born of misunderstanding.
Those with a skeptical view judge it a declaratory meeting without a breakthrough. European countries pushed back, saying “we are not Putin’s friends,” and there is also an analysis that nothing was decided among the great powers.
What is confirmed is that the talks took place and that Russia’s Foreign Ministry released the full text of the declaration. What is not confirmed is whether the U.S. government confirms the Chinese and Russian accounts as the same content, and whether there was a plan to end the war in Ukraine. Today, the White House’s official explanation and the follow-up reactions of European leaders are worth watching.
Yonhap (joint statement, nuclear risk dialogue, 11/19) · Korea Economic Daily (declaration that nuclear war cannot be won, 11/19) · Dong-A Ilbo (peace declaration adopted, 11/19) · Associated Press (account of UN reform and fuel supply agreement, 11/19)
First-ever U.S.-China-Russia summit adopts peace declaration that “nuclear war cannot be won”… U.S. account still pending
The talks held in Shenzhen, China, on the 19th ended after about 1 hour 30 minutes, and China and Russia said they reached agreement on dialogue to reduce nuclear risks and on UN reform.
The leaders of the United States, China and Russia met together for the first time on the 19th in Shenzhen, China. In the city hosting the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin sat around a large round table, and Xi was described as seated effectively in the middle. The talks ended after about 1 hour 30 minutes. Russia’s Foreign Ministry said a peace declaration by the three leaders was adopted and released the full text. The declaration contains wording that nuclear war cannot be won and a pledge to open dialogue to reduce nuclear risks and on nuclear non-proliferation. China and Russia said they also agreed with the United States on UN reform and on expanding fuel supplies, and there were reports that it includes a passage saying bodies such as the International Criminal Court must not abuse their jurisdiction. Xi was reported to have said after the talks that they were “positive and constructive,” and said during the talks that “when the great powers are in harmony the world is at peace, and when they quarrel it falls into chaos.”
On the U.S. side, Trump said on the 19th (local time) that artificial intelligence (AI) safety was discussed with Xi in a limited way, and added an understanding of the position of President Putin, who was angry over Ukrainian forces’ attack on the Crimean Bridge. Putin said there had been no global conflict for 80 years thanks to the Yalta agreement. The Chinese side put forward the message that big countries should join forces to keep the world stable. Cheong Wa Dae issued a position before the talks that it would not be “a second Yalta meeting,” and European countries pushed back, saying “we are not Putin’s friends.” Assessments of the talks range from a declaratory meeting without a breakthrough to an analysis that nothing was decided unilaterally. It is not yet known whether the declaration contains concrete commitments to carry it out or a plan to end the war in Ukraine, or whether the U.S. government will confirm the Chinese and Russian accounts as they stand.