On Oct. 30, Binance said that affected assets came to an estimated $6.3 billion (about 1 trillion yen) and halted withdrawals for users. This is Binance’s own estimate, not a confirmed amount actually lost. The company says it has frozen about $3 billion of it, roughly half. It also explained that it has set aside more than $6.34 billion to make up for the losses. CEO Teng said, “Users’ assets are safe,” and named resuming withdrawals within about 40 hours as the goal. Two private firms, TRM Labs and Chainalysis, point to involvement by the North Korean cyber group “TraderTraitor,” but no identification by a government has been confirmed. Binance explained that the culprits used a self-destruct mechanism to hide their traces. Bitcoin fell to its lowest since September.
The way an exchange holds customers’ assets is close to a bank in that if one point is breached, confidence in deposits as a whole is shaken. If the withdrawal halt drags on, users may try to pull out their assets all at once, and trading disruption could spread. Freezing stolen assets is a race against the time it takes the culprits to cash out.
Individual investors in Japan, too, hold Bitcoin and other assets through overseas exchanges. Assets left on an exchange are directly exposed to a hack or collapse of that exchange. It is an occasion to review where you keep your assets and how you would prepare if you could not withdraw them.
There is a view that the exchange’s response was swift. It quickly showed funds to cover the full loss and set a time goal for resuming withdrawals. The coordination on freezing also worked, and part of the stolen assets can no longer be moved.
There is a view that it weighs heavily that the world’s largest exchange could not prevent the largest theft ever. It is taken as exposing the weakness of keeping assets on an exchange, and has led to calls for user-protection rules and stricter segregation of deposited assets.
What is confirmed is that Binance announced the impact at an estimated $6.3 billion, that about half is frozen, the withdrawal halt, the pointing by private analytics firms to a North Korea-linked group, and the reserve set aside to cover losses. The actual amount lost, the method of intrusion, an identification of the culprits by a government, and when withdrawals will fully resume are not known. We want to watch the Bitcoin market after the weekend and the announcement of resumed withdrawals.
ITmedia NEWS (pointing to involvement by a North Korea-linked group, 10/31) · The Japan Times (moves to freeze assets, 10/30) · Bloomberg Television (announcement of impact of about $6.3 billion, 10/30) · Reuters (reserve to cover losses, 10/30)
Binance Puts Impact at Estimated $6.3 Billion, About Half Frozen; Analytics Firms Point to North Korea-Linked Group
The world’s largest crypto exchange has said the impact of the hack is an estimated $6.3 billion and has halted withdrawals. Two private analytics firms point to involvement by a North Korean cyber group.
Binance, the world’s largest crypto exchange, said on Oct. 30 that assets affected by what appears to be a hack came to an estimated $6.3 billion (about 1 trillion yen), and halted withdrawals for users. The $6.3 billion is Binance’s own estimate; the amount actually lost has not been determined. About $3 billion of it, roughly half, has reportedly been frozen. If the actual damage is on this scale, it would be the largest theft of crypto assets ever. To cover the losses, Binance explained, it has set aside more than $6.34 billion. CEO Teng said, “Users’ assets are safe,” and set a goal of resuming withdrawals within about 40 hours.
The blockchain analytics firms TRM Labs and Chainalysis pointed to suspected involvement by the North Korean cyber group “TraderTraitor.” Both are analyses by private companies, and no identification by a government has been confirmed. Binance has explained that the culprits used a “self-destruct mechanism” to erase their traces. Bitcoin fell to its lowest since September, and co-founder Zhao pushed back against Elon Musk, who had mocked the incident, saying, “This is no time to joke around.” The actual amount lost, the route of the intrusion and when withdrawals will fully resume have not been confirmed.