The United Daily News and the China Times reported that an industrial accident occurred on the afternoon of the 20th at the new P4 construction site in the F22 area of TSMC’s Kaohsiung Nanzi campus: a bolt apparently snapped as a crane was hoisting the steel structure, and 4 subcontractor workers fell with it from a height equal to the third floor. The United Daily News reported that the Bureau’s preliminary account that evening was 2 people in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA), 1 seriously injured and 1 slightly injured. ETtoday reported 3 dead and 1 in critical condition, FTV Finance reported 3 dead and 1 seriously injured, and the evening headlines of the Liberty Times and the United Daily News both said 3 people died. The Southern Taiwan Science Park Bureau ordered work halted, requiring the site to stop all work and the disaster scene not to be disturbed, and will impose penalties under the Occupational Safety and Health Act. CNA and the Liberty Times reported that TSMC said the site falls within the scope of contracted work and that the related work has been halted on its own initiative, with TSMC cooperating with the investigation.
A large plant construction project has cranes, steel structures and high-altitude welding going on at once, and the failure of a single connecting piece can bring down a whole assembly together with the workers. TSMC handed the work to contractors, so how legal responsibility is divided depends on how the authorities determine the obligations of the businesses, the contractors and the employers.
People who work in science parks and on large construction sites can check whether the area under the hoisting route at their own site is off limits to people, and whether workers at height actually use safety harnesses and fall-protection equipment. For general readers: casualty figures often change on the night of an accident, so go by the authorities’ later announcements.
The Southern Taiwan Science Park Bureau’s position is that the cause is under investigation; for now it has confirmed the apparent bolt failure, the stop-work and the ban on moving the scene, and will then determine violations and penalties according to law (United Daily News, China Times). This side stresses procedure and the assignment of responsibility.
TSMC’s position is that the site falls within the scope of contracted work, that it has halted work on its own initiative and is urging the subcontractor to handle follow-up matters (CNA, Liberty Times). This side puts treating the injured and the families first while cooperating with the investigation. The papers’ differing casualty figures also leave outsiders with differing views of how serious the accident is.
What is confirmed: the accident happened at the new P4 site, 4 subcontractor workers fell, the Bureau ordered work halted and TSMC halted work on its own. What is unconfirmed: the final death toll and the reason the bolt broke. Next to watch: the Southern Taiwan Science Park Bureau’s labor inspection findings and penalties, and whether TSMC explains any effect on the Nanzi build-out schedule.
United Daily News (Steel beam falls, 3 dead, 1 injured, stop-work ordered, Oct. 20) · Liberty Times (Causing 3 deaths, P4 steel-structure hoisting work halted, Oct. 20) · CNA (TSMC: related work halted on its own, Oct. 20) · PTS (3 of 4 fallen workers in OHCA, Oct. 20) · ETtoday (4 people fall with the steel structure, Oct. 20) · FTV Finance (3 dead, 1 seriously injured, Oct. 20) · China Times (Cause of accident revealed, stop-work and penalties, Oct. 20)
Steel structure falls at TSMC’s new P4 site in Kaohsiung’s Nanzi; 4 subcontractor workers plunge, reports say 3 dead, Southern Taiwan Science Park Bureau orders work halted
The Southern Taiwan Science Park Bureau said a bolt apparently snapped on the afternoon of the 20th as a crane was hoisting the steel structure, and 4 workers fell from a height; TSMC said the related work has been halted on its own initiative and that it is cooperating with the investigation.
An industrial accident occurred on the afternoon of the 20th at the new P4 construction site in the F22 area of TSMC’s Kaohsiung Nanzi campus. The United Daily News and the China Times reported that a bolt apparently snapped as a crane was hoisting the steel structure, and 4 subcontractor workers who were welding fell with the structure from a height equal to the third floor; the Science Park Bureau’s preliminary investigation points the same way. The accident happened in the third-floor steel-structure work area, all of the injured are subcontractor personnel, and the Bureau said it will send officials for a labor inspection. Casualty figures differ between the papers: the United Daily News reported that the Bureau’s preliminary account that evening was 2 people in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA), 1 seriously injured and 1 slightly injured; ETtoday reported “3 dead, 1 in critical condition,” FTV Finance reported “3 dead, 1 seriously injured,” the Liberty Times’ evening headline was “causing 3 deaths,” and the United Daily News’ evening headline was “Steel beam falls, 3 dead, 1 injured.”
The Bureau has issued a stop-work order, requiring the site to stop all work and the disaster scene not to be disturbed; it will then determine under the Occupational Safety and Health Act whether the businesses and employers involved broke the law before deciding on penalties (United Daily News, China Times). TSMC told CNA and the Liberty Times that the site falls within the scope of contracted work, that the related work has been halted on its own initiative, and that it is cooperating with the relevant agencies’ investigation while urging the subcontractor to handle follow-up matters. PTS reported that 3 of the 4 fallen workers were in OHCA. The Commercial Times and the Liberty Times reported that TSMC said the cause of the accident still has to be clarified and that it will urge and assist the subcontractor and help the families with follow-up matters. The Bureau said it will keep watching the treatment of the injured and help arrange condolence visits to the families of the deceased. All the papers describe the cause as an “apparent” bolt failure; the results of the investigation have not been released.