A federal grand jury in Washington, D.C., on Tuesday, Oct. 27, rejected the Justice Department's attempt to indict Cassidy Hutchinson over her testimony to lawmakers about President Trump's actions during the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol, The Hill reported. ABC News reported that sources confirmed a grand jury refused to indict her on charges of lying to Congress. Fox News reported that the panel declined to charge her over statements made to the Jan. 6 House select committee. NBC News headlined the outcome citing a U.S. official, and PBS NewsHour carried an Associated Press report citing the agency's sources. CBS News reported that federal prosecutors in Washington failed to secure the indictment. The New York Times called it the latest extraordinary setback in Trump's campaign to go after his political opponents, and NBC News reported that the failed indictment is one of many for federal prosecutors during the second Trump administration.
A grand jury is a panel of citizens that reviews prosecutors' evidence in secret and decides whether to approve a felony charge, and it usually approves what prosecutors request, so a refusal is unusual and mostly becomes public through sources. The case matters because Hutchinson was one of the committee's best-known witnesses, which places the attempt inside the wider dispute over whether the Justice Department is pursuing people the president has criticized. A refusal does not bar prosecutors from asking again, so the practical effect depends on what the department does next.
If you follow the courts or the midterms, this is one more data point on how Washington grand juries are treating requests from the department. For most readers nothing changes directly, but the decision shows that charges against prominent critics can stall before a case ever becomes public.
The administration's side, as the reports describe the department's effort, is that prosecutors believed Hutchinson made false statements to Congress and were entitled to ask a grand jury to review that. In this view, a refusal in secret proceedings is part of the ordinary process and does not settle whether her testimony was accurate.
The critics' side, as the New York Times framed it, is that the refusal is the latest extraordinary setback in Trump's wide-ranging campaign against his political opponents, and PBS NewsHour called it the latest setback in efforts to charge his perceived adversaries. In this view, a grand jury declining to act is a sign the case was weak.
Confirmed across outlets: a Washington grand jury declined to indict Hutchinson on Tuesday, according to sources cited by NBC News, ABC News and the Associated Press. Not confirmed in the reports cited: the vote, the exact charges drafted, any Justice Department comment and whether prosecutors will try again. Watch for a department statement and for any sign that another grand jury is asked.
NBC News (declines to indict, 10/27) · The New York Times (setback, 10/27) · The Hill (rejected attempt, 10/27) · Axios (another blow, 10/27) · CBS News (failed to secure indictment, 10/27) · ABC News (lying to Congress, 10/27) · Fox News (House committee statements, 10/27) · PBS NewsHour (AP report, 10/27)
Federal grand jury declines to indict Cassidy Hutchinson, the former White House aide who testified about Jan. 6Federal grand jury declines to indict Cassidy Hutchinson, the former White House aide who testified about Jan. 6
NBC News, ABC News and PBS NewsHour, citing sources, report a Washington grand jury refused the Justice Department's request to charge the former Jan. 6 committee witness.
A federal grand jury in Washington, D.C., on Tuesday, Oct. 27, rejected the Justice Department's attempt to indict Cassidy Hutchinson over her testimony to lawmakers about President Trump's actions during the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol, The Hill reported. ABC News reported that sources confirmed a grand jury refused to indict her on charges of lying to Congress, and Fox News reported that the panel declined to charge her over statements made to the Jan. 6 House select committee. NBC News headlined the outcome citing a U.S. official, and PBS NewsHour carried an Associated Press report that cited the agency's sources. CBS News reported that federal prosecutors in Washington failed to secure an indictment against Hutchinson, whom it described as a Trump critic.
The New York Times, in a breaking-news post, described her as the former White House aide Trump targeted after she gave damning testimony about Jan. 6, and called the rejection the latest extraordinary setback in his wide-ranging campaign to go after his political opponents. PBS NewsHour called it the latest setback in the Justice Department's efforts to charge Trump's perceived adversaries. NBC News reported that the failed indictment is one of many for federal prosecutors during the second Trump administration, and Axios, noting that multiple outlets reported the outcome on Tuesday, described the grand jury's refusal as another blow. The reports cited do not include a Justice Department response, a vote count or word on whether prosecutors will ask another grand jury to act.