Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that the Democratic Party of Korea, after a closed-door caucus meeting on the 27th, decided to hold a parliamentary investigation into allegations including abuse of power by Chief Justice Cho Hee-de. Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that floor spokesperson Jeon Eun-su answered ‘That’s right’ when asked whether the goal is to put it to a plenary session on Nov. 5. Dong-A Ilbo reported that Rep. Kim Hyun-jung said the caucus position is to collect evidence on the controversy over business promotion expenses and other matters, and that no one talked about impeaching. Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon’s acquittal at the second trial acted as the trigger for the push for a parliamentary investigation. Dong-A Ilbo reported that People Power Party chief spokesperson Park Chung-kwon commented that ‘refusal to accept a ruling has been disguised as a parliamentary investigation’. Yonhap reported that the People Power Party defined the parliamentary investigation as ‘grounds for impeaching President Lee Jae-myung and the ruling party’ and said it would mount national resistance. SBS reported that the Democratic Party aims to pass it at the plenary session on the 5th of next month.
A parliamentary investigation is a procedure in which the National Assembly looks into the facts of a particular matter, so when its target is the chief justice, it bears directly on the boundary between judicial independence and the Assembly’s powers. With the target date set for Nov. 5, the schedule of a little over nine days becomes the deadline for negotiations between the parties and for the judiciary’s response.
Because an investigation surrounding the chief justice concerns trust in trials and the separation of powers, how the scope and witnesses are set in the investigation plan affects trust in the judicial system. There is nothing for readers to do separately; just check whether it is put to the Nov. 5 plenary session.
According to Kyunghyang Shinmun and Dong-A Ilbo, the Democratic Party believes the controversy over political interference and the allegations of abuse of power surrounding the head of the judiciary must be made fully clear. Floor leader Han Byung-do said it must be determined whether the chief justice fulfilled the duty to defend the Constitution during the insurrection and how the chief justice came to refuse the request for a re-recommendation of a Supreme Court justice candidate, and Rep. Kim Hyun-jung said the parliamentary investigation is for collecting evidence and that there was no discussion of impeachment.
According to Dong-A Ilbo, the People Power Party believes a ruling it refuses to accept has been turned into a parliamentary investigation, and that the investigation is a disguised tactic to impeach Chief Justice Cho. Chief spokesperson Park Chung-kwon noted that six days earlier a Democratic Party spokesperson had called the investigation ‘a procedure to confirm concrete grounds for impeachment’. Yonhap reported that the People Power Party defined the parliamentary investigation as grounds for impeachment.
What is confirmed is that the Democratic Party concluded it would hold a parliamentary investigation and aims to pass it at the plenary session on Nov. 5. The scope of the investigation, the witness list, whether the People Power Party will cooperate and the court’s position are unconfirmed. After today, we will watch when the investigation request is submitted and how the outcome of Kim Keon-hee’s additional detention warrant affects this dispute.
Kyunghyang Shinmun (decision to pursue parliamentary investigation, 10/27) · Dong-A Ilbo (caucus conclusion, PPP commentary, 10/27) · Yonhap (PPP reaction, 10/27) · SBS (plenary session target, 10/27)
Democratic Party moves for parliamentary investigation of Chief Justice Cho Hee-de… aims to pass it at Nov. 5 plenary session
The Democratic Party of Korea decided at a caucus meeting to hold a parliamentary investigation into the allegations surrounding Chief Justice Cho Hee-de, while the People Power Party demanded it stop, calling it ‘killing Cho Hee-de’.
Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that the Democratic Party of Korea, after a closed-door caucus meeting on the 27th, decided to pursue a parliamentary investigation into allegations including abuse of power by Chief Justice Cho Hee-de. Floor spokesperson Jeon Eun-su said at a briefing that ‘opinion converged that a parliamentary investigation should be held’, and Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that when asked whether the goal is to put it to a plenary session on Nov. 5, he answered ‘That’s right’. According to Dong-A Ilbo, floor leader Han Byung-do said at that morning’s meeting that the controversy over political interference and the allegations of abuse of power surrounding the head of the judiciary must be cleared up, and that it must be determined whether the chief justice fulfilled the duty to defend the Constitution during the insurrection and how the chief justice came to refuse the Cheong Wa Dae’s request for a re-recommendation of a Supreme Court justice candidate. Dong-A Ilbo reported that Rep. Kim Hyun-jung said the caucus position is to collect evidence on the controversy over business promotion expenses and other matters, and that ‘no one talked about impeaching’.
Kyunghyang Shinmun reported that the ruling party and Chief Justice Cho have been in conflict over matters including the reversal and remand in President Lee Jae-myung’s trial and the re-recommendation of a Supreme Court justice, and that Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon’s recent acquittal at the second trial acted as the ‘trigger’ for the push for a parliamentary investigation. Dong-A Ilbo reported that People Power Party chief spokesperson Park Chung-kwon said in a commentary that ‘refusal to accept a ruling has been disguised as a parliamentary investigation’, demanded an immediate end to ‘killing Cho Hee-de’, and criticized the push as a disguised tactic for impeachment. Yonhap reported that the People Power Party defined the parliamentary investigation as ‘grounds for impeaching President Lee Jae-myung and the ruling party’ and said it would mount national resistance. Yonhap reported that People Power Party floor leader Jeong Jeom-sik said a parliamentary investigation into the ‘3+1 fabrication special counsel’ should come before the special counsel on dropping prosecutions. Dong-A Ilbo noted that six days earlier a Democratic Party spokesperson had called the parliamentary investigation ‘a procedure to confirm concrete grounds for impeachment’. In a separate article, Kyunghyang Shinmun ran the headline ‘Successive acquittals in the Myung Tae-kyun gate brought on the Cho Hee-de parliamentary investigation’. SBS reported that the Democratic Party aims to pass it at the plenary session on the 5th of next month.