Foreign Minister Cho Hyun, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Japanese Foreign Minister Motegi Toshimitsu held a Korea-US-Japan foreign ministers’ meeting in Atlanta, in the United States, on the 30th (local time). It was held on the sidelines of the Group of 20 (G20) foreign ministers’ meeting, about a month after the September meeting in New York. The three ministers reaffirmed their commitment to the complete denuclearization of North Korea and the full implementation of UN Security Council resolutions. They urged North Korea to join efforts to ease tensions and settle peace, and agreed to maintain a deterrence posture while pursuing dialogue and diplomacy in parallel. They highly praised the work of the Multilateral Sanctions Monitoring Team (MSMT) and signed a memorandum of cooperation on the Pacific Arctic waters. The US State Department said Secretary Rubio raised China’s coercive behavior in the Yellow Sea, but the Foreign Ministry’s release does not contain this.
Even for the same meeting, which sentences go into an official document differs by country. The three countries confirmed the denuclearization principle in the same sentence, but only the US put in wording aimed at China. Korea is pushing to resume North Korea-US dialogue, so adding China-related wording would raise its diplomatic burden. The Arctic memorandum of cooperation matters as the first signing that widens security coordination into maritime and economic cooperation.
If North Korea-US dialogue opens, the geopolitical risk weighing on Korean Peninsula tension, the exchange rate and the stock market will change. How strongly China is addressed is also a variable that affects Korean companies’ exports and supply chains. It will not change daily life right away, but it is worth watching whether Yellow Sea wording appears in later three-way documents.
View favoring parallel dialogue. It holds that keeping a deterrence posture while leaving the door to dialogue open is the realistic way to manage tension. As Minister Cho’s ‘pacemaker’ remark suggests, Korea can take on the role of creating a point of contact between North Korea and the US, and it explains that wording that does not directly target China preserves room for negotiation.
View favoring checking China. It reads the absence of even one line about the Yellow Sea from Korea’s release, while China’s coercion continues in the Yellow Sea and the South China Sea, as a crack in three-way coordination. Because security cooperation gains deterrent force only when allies send the same message, it argues Korea should speak at the same level.
What is confirmed is the reaffirmed commitment to denuclearization, the signing of the Arctic memorandum of cooperation and the praise for the MSMT’s work. What is not confirmed is whether the Yellow Sea issue will go into joint three-way wording and whether North Korea-US dialogue will actually open. Today, watch whether the Foreign Ministry offers any further explanation on the Yellow Sea passage and whether the Chinese side reacts to the US raising it.
Dong-A Ilbo (Korea-US-Japan foreign ministers reaffirm denuclearization, 10/31) · Yonhap (US raises Yellow Sea coercion, 10/31) · Chosun Ilbo (Korean release compared with US release, 10/31)
Korea, US, Japan foreign ministers reaffirm ‘complete denuclearization’ of North Korea… only the US raises ‘Chinese coercion in the Yellow Sea’
Meeting again after about a month, the three ministers in Atlanta on the 30th urged North Korea to engage in dialogue and signed an Arctic cooperation memorandum. Wording aimed at China went only into the US document.
Foreign Minister Cho Hyun, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Japanese Foreign Minister Motegi Toshimitsu held a Korea-US-Japan foreign ministers’ meeting in Atlanta, in the United States, on the 30th (local time) and reaffirmed their firm commitment to the complete denuclearization of North Korea and the full implementation of UN Security Council resolutions. The meeting was held on the sidelines of the Group of 20 (G20) foreign ministers’ meeting, about a month after the September meeting in New York. The three ministers urged North Korea to join efforts to ease tensions and settle peace, and agreed to maintain a deterrence posture while pursuing denuclearization efforts through dialogue and diplomacy in parallel. They also highly praised the work of the Multilateral Sanctions Monitoring Team (MSMT), which has been uncovering North Korea’s sanctions violations and evasion. Minister Cho said Korea would play a “pacemaker” role in resuming North Korea-US dialogue. The three countries also signed a memorandum of cooperation (MOC) to expand maritime safety and economic cooperation in the Pacific Arctic waters, and confirmed coordination on economic security areas such as supply chains, small modular reactors (SMR) and artificial intelligence (AI).
The documents the two countries issued on the same meeting carry different weight. The US State Department said Secretary Rubio raised China’s attempts to secure control of the South China Sea, its coercive behavior in the East China Sea and the Yellow Sea, and the problem of cooperation between China and Russia that undermines peace and stability in the Indo-Pacific. The Foreign Ministry’s release, by contrast, has no passage on the Yellow Sea, and puts dialogue and diplomacy first. The Korean and Japanese accounts do not mention this passage either. Minister Cho also discussed bilateral relations, high-level exchanges and visa issues separately with Secretary Rubio. Whether wording aimed at China will go into a joint three-way statement, and whether North Korea-US dialogue will actually resume, has not yet been decided. The date of the next meeting of the three ministers has not been made public.