The ‘fabricated-prosecution special counsel act’ passed a plenary session of the National Assembly on the 6th. With 168 members present, it passed 167 to 1, and the one vote against was cast by Rep. Lee Ju-young of the Reform Party. People Power Party lawmakers did not take part in the vote. The Democratic Party ended the People Power Party’s filibuster by a vote after a little over 24 hours and then passed the bill at the plenary session at 4 p.m. that day. Under the act, the Democratic Party, the People Power Party and the Rebuilding Korea Party each recommend one candidate and the president appoints one of them, and after a 20-day preparation period a special counsel team of up to 309 members is formed. The investigation covers six cases in which President Lee Jae-myung has been indicted. The version that passed was revised by the Legislation and Judiciary Committee on the 4th, and the withdrawal-of-prosecution clause was dropped. The People Power Party said it will begin a street campaign from the 7th.
A special counsel is a device that sets up investigators and powers separate from the prosecution, so who recommends the candidates and who appoints one leads straight to the question of the investigation’s neutrality. The president’s own cases are within the scope of the investigation and the power of appointment also rests with the president, so the structure itself, apart from the bill’s purpose, has become the point at issue. If the opposition stays out of votes and takes to the streets, negotiations on the rest of the Assembly’s calendar, including the budget bill, could become difficult.
This is not a law that changes daily life right away, but if the political conflict drags on, passage of the budget bill and of bills affecting people’s livelihoods could be delayed. Which cases become targets of investigation, and on what grounds, is best judged by checking the text of the law and its start date yourself.
The ruling side holds that allegations of fabricated investigations and fabricated prosecutions by the Yoon Suk Yeol government’s prosecutors should be uncovered by a separate investigation rather than by state agencies. It explains that the revised version, with the withdrawal-of-prosecution clause removed, eased concerns in the opposition and the legal community, and that having three parties recommend candidates struck a balance.
The opposition and part of the legal community criticize it as a privatization of the justice system, since a special counsel appointed by the president would re-examine the president’s own trial cases. Even inside the ruling Democratic Party, Rep. Chung Sung-ho said more deliberation was needed, and Cho Kuk pointed out that applying the old Criminal Procedure Act raises a risk of unconstitutionality.
What is confirmed: the vote result (167 for, 1 against), the way the special counsel is appointed, the deletion of the withdrawal-of-prosecution clause, and the opposition’s announced street campaign from the 7th. What is not confirmed: when the law will be promulgated, the schedule for recommending special counsel candidates, and whether a constitutional complaint or a constitutional review is filed. What to watch today: the size of the rally outside the Assembly and whether the negotiations between the ruling and opposition parties spill over into the budget bill.
Dong-A Ilbo (vote result on the special counsel act’s passage in the Assembly, 11/6) · Kyunghyang Shinmun (seventh special counsel under the current government, 11/6) · SBS (passage led by the Democratic Party and People Power Party backlash, 11/6) · Korea Economic Daily (opposition announces street campaign, 11/6)
‘Fabricated-prosecution special counsel act’ passes Assembly… 167 for, 1 against; People Power Party skips vote, takes to the streets from the 7th
The National Assembly passed the fabricated-prosecution special counsel act at a plenary session on the 6th, 167 to 1. The People Power Party did not take part in the vote and begins a street campaign on the 7th.
The ‘fabricated-prosecution special counsel act’ passed a plenary session of the National Assembly on the 6th. Its formal title is the ‘Act on the Appointment of a Special Counsel, etc. for Uncovering the Truth Behind Allegations of Fabricated Investigations and Fabricated Prosecutions by State Agencies Including the Yoon Suk Yeol Government’s Prosecutors’ Office, National Intelligence Service and Board of Audit and Inspection.’ The Democratic Party ended by a vote, after a little over 24 hours, the filibuster (unlimited debate) the People Power Party had kept up since the 5th, and at the plenary session at 4 p.m. that day it passed the bill with 168 members present, 167 in favor and 1 against. The one vote against was cast by Rep. Lee Ju-young of the Reform Party, and People Power Party lawmakers did not take part in the vote. It is the seventh special counsel since the Lee Jae-myung government took office. When the Democratic Party, the People Power Party and the Rebuilding Korea Party each recommend one candidate, President Lee Jae-myung appoints one of them, and after a 20-day preparation period a special counsel team of up to 309 members is formed.
The investigation covers six cases in which President Lee has been indicted. The version that passed is the one the Legislation and Judiciary Committee revised on the 4th, and the contested clause on withdrawal of prosecution was dropped. The bill has the special counsel look into allegations of fabricated investigations and fabricated prosecutions, such as selecting or omitting evidence and using illegally collected evidence. The People Power Party called it ‘bulletproof legislation’ aimed at President Lee’s cases and said it would begin a street campaign from the 7th. Former Prosecutor General Lee Won-seok criticized it as unconstitutional legislation that destroys the separation of powers. Rep. Chung Sung-ho of the ruling Democratic Party said in a radio interview that day, “I get the feeling that a bit more deliberation was needed.” Cho Kuk, head of the Rebuilding Korea Party’s Innovation Policy Institute, wrote on Facebook that the provision having the special counsel apply the old Criminal Procedure Act, which has already lost effect, raises problems of unconstitutionality and illegality. The date the law will be promulgated and the schedule for recommending special counsel candidates have not yet been announced.