On the 11th the Fair Trade Commission said it would issue a corrective order and impose penalty surcharges totaling 1.626575 trillion won on 15 Korea Treasury Bond primary dealers. The 10 securities firms account for 1.376 trillion won in total and the 5 banks for 250.5 billion won. By firm, KB Securities was fined the most at 332.2 billion won, followed by NH Investment & Securities at 242.8 billion won and Mirae Asset Securities at 214.8 billion won. The commission judged that the 15 firms exchanged bid rates and information in 150 Treasury bond auctions from January 2020 to June 2023, and agreed on volumes as well in 145 of them. Seven firms (Mirae Asset Securities, NH Investment & Securities, Industrial Bank of Korea, KB Securities, Kiwoom Securities, Korea Development Bank and Korea Investment & Securities) will be reported to the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency. The Korea Financial Investment Association said the sanctions are excessive and that it would actively support lawsuits, and the Ministry of Economy and Finance said it would review whether to suspend or revoke dealer status after the decision is finalized.
Treasury bond auctions are where the government decides at what rate it will borrow. The commission sees the collusion as having kept winning rates from falling, raising the government’s financing cost. Conversely, if dealer status is restricted, the number of channels to take up government bonds could shrink, so the balance between sanctions and stable issuance has become an issue.
Treasury bond yields serve as a benchmark for loan and deposit rates and for bond prices, and so connect to households’ interest burdens. But how much this decision actually moved market rates has not been confirmed. It is worth checking the Treasury bond issuance schedule around the time the lawsuit outcome and the dealer-status measures emerge.
The commission’s view holds that coordinating bid rates and volumes before auctions blocked competition. Because the 15 firms repeated it across 150 auctions over three and a half years, and some agreed on volumes as well, its position is that this is a case that calls for the largest-ever penalty surcharge and criminal complaints.
The industry’s view counters that dealers act as market makers and merely exchanged ordinary market trends. The Korea Financial Investment Association worried that the sanctions are excessive and that restricting dealer status could disrupt Treasury bond issuance.
What is confirmed is the commission’s decision to impose penalty surcharges, the amounts by firm, the plan to report 7 firms, and the Ministry of Economy and Finance’s stance of holding off on status measures. Not confirmed are whether the amounts will stand in court, what measures will come on dealer status, and how much the collusion actually raised rates. Watch whether the firms that receive the written decision file suits to cancel it and applications for a stay of enforcement.
Yonhap (industry reaction and hint of legal response, 11/11) · Newstop (penalty surcharges by firm and referral targets, 11/11) · InvestChosun (securities industry prepares lawsuit, 11/11) · Financial News (size and calculation of penalty surcharges, 11/11)
15 firms hit with 1.6265 trillion won in penalty surcharges for rigging Treasury bond auctions… biggest ever in a single Fair Trade Commission case, 7 reported to the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency
The Fair Trade Commission found that 15 banks and securities firms coordinated rates and volumes in advance in Treasury bond auctions. The industry has signaled lawsuits.
On the 11th the Fair Trade Commission said it would issue a corrective order and impose penalty surcharges totaling 1.626575 trillion won on 15 Korea Treasury Bond primary dealers (PD), saying they had coordinated their bid submission rates and winning volumes in advance, or exchanged information, in competitive Treasury bond auctions. It is the largest penalty surcharge the commission has ever imposed in a single case. The previous record was 1.0311 trillion won in the 2016 Qualcomm case. The targets are 10 securities firms and 5 banks; the securities firms were fined 1.376 trillion won in total and the banks 250.5 billion won in total. By firm, KB Securities was fined the most at 332.2 billion won, followed by NH Investment & Securities at 242.8 billion won and Mirae Asset Securities at 214.8 billion won. Penalty surcharges are money an administrative agency imposes on companies that break the law, and differ from fines imposed in criminal trials.
The commission said the collusion ran from January 2020 to June 2023 and covered 150 auctions. In 145 of them, it judged, the firms went beyond exchanging information and agreed on volumes as well. Seven firms with long collusion periods and many auctions taken part in (Mirae Asset Securities, NH Investment & Securities, Industrial Bank of Korea, KB Securities, Kiwoom Securities, Korea Development Bank and Korea Investment & Securities) will be reported to the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency. The Korea Financial Investment Association said the sanctions are excessive and that it would actively support the industry’s lawsuits, and industry observers expect suits to cancel the decision and applications for a stay of enforcement as soon as the written decision is received. The Ministry of Economy and Finance said it would review whether to suspend or revoke dealer status after the decision is finalized. It is not yet known whether the penalty surcharges will be finalized or how they might change in court.