On Saturday, October 17, during the demonstrations against the cost of living, there were scuffles in Piazza del Duomo and Piazza Cordusio in Milan. ANSA, La Stampa and Google News report stones thrown at police, paper bombs, fireworks, charges, injured and detained. In the evening ANSA gave about 50 detained in Milan, almost half of them minors. In Bologna the clashes in front of the station led, according to the evening toll, to the arrest of four minors and 36 injured among law enforcement; in the afternoon the detained were seven. In Turin ANSA reported a scuffle among demonstrators and chants against Meloni and Vannacci. Meloni declared that any reticence about street violence becomes justification and the mayor of Milan, Sala, spoke of understandable reasons and unjustifiable violence.
The clashes shift the debate from the cost of living to public order, and those who were in the square to protest risk being identified with the violence of a few. For shopkeepers in central Milan and for police officers, the toll of damage and injuries weighs more than the march’s slogan.
If you live or work in the affected areas, check official updates on closed roads and transport before heading out. If you want to understand what happened, read more than one account: the numbers of detained and injured change from one hour to the next.
Condemning violence is easy; explaining why so many young people take to the streets is harder. The real test is whether it will be possible to discuss the cost of living without the debate being reduced to stones.
ANSA, La Stampa, Google News
March over the cost of living: clashes in Milan and Bologna, Meloni asks the opposition to condemn the violence
Stones, paper bombs and fireworks thrown at police at the Duomo and in Piazza Cordusio; meanwhile in Rome the Cgil announces a general strike for November 20.
On Saturday, October 17, several Italian squares filled up for a protest against the rising cost of living, and in Milan the march turned violent over the course of the afternoon. ANSA reports scuffles in Piazza del Duomo and in Piazza Cordusio, with police pelted by groups of youths dressed in black; ANSA, La Stampa and Google News speak of stones thrown at officers, of paper bombs and fireworks, of charges by law enforcement, of injured and of detained. In the evening the agency said that about 50 people were detained in Milan and that almost half of them are minors, headlining that the cost-of-living protest had turned into guerrilla warfare and that the city had looked like a battlefield.
The tensions did not stop at Milan. In Turin the demonstration opened with chants against Meloni and against Vannacci; participants repeated that they were non-partisan, and students and social centres were also in the square, then there were moments of scuffling. In Bologna there were clashes in front of the station between young demonstrators and law enforcement: in the afternoon ANSA counted seven demonstrators detained, while the evening toll speaks of four minors arrested and 36 injured among law enforcement. In Bologna, Lepore declared that devastation and violence have no justification.
The government’s response came in the evening. Meloni declared that any reticence about street violence becomes justification and spoke of thugs who exploit demonstrations to sow chaos; she also asked the opposition to condemn the violence at the students’ marches. Foreign Minister Tajani called the violence unacceptable and attacked those in the opposition who stoke the fire, expressing solidarity with the men and women in uniform. The mayor of Milan, Sala, spoke of understandable reasons but unjustifiable violence.
The day also had a political and union side. In Rome, in the square with the Cgil, Landini announced that on November 20 the union will proclaim a general strike; Conte said the Five Star Movement (M5S) is ready and hoped that talks among the opposition parties would begin within days, while Schlein spoke of the spirit of the referendum and of the will to build the alternative together. Still to be clarified are the final toll of injured and detained in the three cities and who promoted the marches that turned violent: the sources consulted do not attribute the violence to an organizer.
By the numbers
Word of the day
paper bombsPublic orderCrude devices that go off with a loud bang, often thrown at law enforcement in marches.