On November 5, President Putin signed a presidential decree placing four Russian subsidiaries of the Japan Tobacco (JT) group temporarily under the control of Russian companies. Those covered include “JTI Donskoy Tabak,” which runs the Russian business of JT’s overseas subsidiary JT International (JTI). The group’s four factories in Russia also come under the control of Russian companies. Ownership remains with the companies, but the authority to manage is effectively lost. In September as well, Russia placed the Russian assets of Nestlé of Switzerland and Auchan of France under provisional control. The Japanese government plans to protest to Russia. JT shares were sold down to the limit-down level in off-exchange trading after regular exchange trading had ended. The duration of the control and the conditions for returning the assets had not been made clear as of the night of the 5th.
It sets a precedent in which a Japanese company’s overseas assets are effectively held by the other country’s government amid a diplomatic dispute. Even if ownership remains, without management rights the company itself cannot decide how to run the factories or what to do with the profits. Russia has already used the method of entrusting foreign companies’ assets to Russian firms in the form of “temporary management” on Nestlé and others, and now that the targets have widened to a major Japanese tobacco company, other Japanese companies that keep business in Russia cannot help but consider that they may receive the same measure.
People who hold JT shares, or hold them indirectly through investment trusts or pensions, will want to check the share price and the company’s explanations. People who work for companies with business or trading partners in Russia should watch the policy their company issues on Russian assets and contracts. No effect on retail tobacco prices has been indicated at this point.
The Japanese government’s position is that it will protest to Russia over what it sees as a unilateral measure against a Japanese company’s assets. It is expected to seek through diplomatic channels a withdrawal of the measure or a minimizing of its effects, and protecting JT’s employees and business is the immediate task.
Russia’s position is that the control under the decree is only “temporary” and does not transfer ownership itself. Because ownership remains, room for a future return or for talks legally remains. But the timing and conditions of a return have not yet been shown.
What we can confirm is that the decree was signed; that it covers four Russian subsidiaries of JT and four factories in Russia; that ownership remains while management effectively passes to Russian companies; and that the Japanese government plans to protest. What we cannot confirm is the duration of the control, the conditions for return, Russia’s explanation of its reasons for the measure, and the specific effect on JT’s employees and shipments. Today we will watch the Japanese government’s formal protest and what JT announces, and how JT shares move in the Tokyo market on the 6th.
NHK (content of the decree, 11/5) · Asahi Shimbun (decree signed, 11/5) · Mainichi Shimbun (Japanese government’s plan to protest, 11/5) · Nikkei (four companies covered and management rights, 11/5)
Russia Puts Four JT Subsidiaries Under Temporary Control; Putin Signs Decree, Japan to Protest
The subsidiaries that run Japan Tobacco’s business in Russia are covered. Ownership remains, but management effectively passes into the hands of Russian companies.
On November 5, Russian President Putin signed a presidential decree placing four Russian subsidiaries of the Japan Tobacco (JT) group temporarily under the control of Russian companies. Those covered include “JTI Donskoy Tabak,” which runs the Russian business of JT’s overseas subsidiary JT International (JTI), and the group’s four factories in Russia also come under the control of Russian companies. Ownership remains with the companies, but the authority to manage is effectively lost. The measure of entrusting foreign companies’ assets to domestic firms under the name of “temporary management” was applied in September to Nestlé of Switzerland and Auchan of France; this is the first time it has been applied to a major tobacco company.
The Japanese government plans to protest to Russia. As of the night of the 5th, no official explanation had been made public of why Russia took the measure. JT shares were sold down to the limit-down level in off-exchange trading after regular exchange trading had ended. How long the control will last and whether the assets will be returned are unclear, and the focus is on the outlook for the business JT has continued in Russia.