U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the Justice Department's lawsuit against Alaska on Sunday, Nov. 1. The suit was filed in late October at President Trump's direction. It asked the court to bar the state from certifying a Senate winner if the winner is not incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan. The government's stated worry is that a second candidate named Dan Sullivan, listed on the ballot, will confuse voters and pull votes from the senator. The suit also asked that certain ballots be separated and preserved. Sullivan said Sunday, “I'm going to accept the election results.” Election Day is Tuesday, Nov. 3.
A federal court has now refused to let the Justice Department set conditions on a Senate result before any votes are counted. The race is tight, so any dispute over how ballots are handled carries weight. The ruling does not decide the race itself; it removes one legal obstacle to counting and certifying whatever the voters choose.
If you vote in Alaska, your ballot lists two candidates named Dan Sullivan, so check which is which before you mark it. Everywhere else, the case is a test of how far the federal government can go in shaping rules for a result days before the vote. In a close race, final results can take longer to settle.
The administration's side argues that two candidates with the same name on one ballot invite honest mistakes, and that the senator should not lose votes to a look-alike entry. In this view, preserving ballots protects against a result no one can untangle later. Trump has also written on Truth Social that the second Sullivan has “DISAPPEARED”; no official has confirmed that.
Opponents of the suit argue the government sued before a single vote was counted and asked a court to prejudge a result. They say the state already has procedures for counting and certifying votes and that a federal court should not tilt them toward one party. Sullivan himself said he will accept the results, though he also suggested the election could be “stolen.”
Settled: the case is dismissed and the incumbent says he will accept the count. Not settled: the judge's full reasoning, whether the Justice Department appeals, whether Sullivan's claim about Peltola's campaign is ever established (she has denied it), and where the second Sullivan is, which Trump asserts but no official has confirmed. Watch Monday for any appeal and Tuesday night for how the two Sullivans divide the vote.
NBC News (judge dismisses suit, Nov. 1) · The Hill (Gleason ruling, Nov. 1) · The New York Times (dismissal, Nov. 1) · CNBC (Sullivan will accept results, Nov. 1)
Federal judge dismisses Justice Department suit that sought to block Alaska's Senate result if Republican Dan Sullivan losesFederal judge dismisses Justice Department suit that sought to block Alaska's Senate result if Republican Dan Sullivan loses
Two days before the vote, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason throws out the case built around a second candidate named Dan Sullivan, and the senator says he will accept the result.
A federal judge in Alaska dismissed the Justice Department's lawsuit against the state on Sunday, ending a case brought at President Trump's direction that asked the court to keep Alaska from certifying a Senate winner if the Republican incumbent, Dan Sullivan, loses. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason issued the dismissal in federal district court; her full reasoning has not been made public in the material we could confirm. The government's argument was that a second candidate on the ballot, also named Dan Sullivan, could confuse voters, draw votes away from the senator and help Democrat Mary Peltola, a former congresswoman. The suit also asked that certain ballots be set apart and preserved. Election Day is Tuesday.
Sullivan said in a Sunday television interview, “I'm going to accept the election results,” even if he loses, while also suggesting the election could be “stolen.” He has accused Peltola of lying about her campaign's involvement with the second Sullivan's candidacy; Peltola's campaign has denied it, and no court has ruled on the charge. On Truth Social, Trump wrote that the second candidate has “DISAPPEARED”; no official has confirmed that. An FBI agent has visited a donor to the second Sullivan's campaign at a boat dealership in Petersburg, the fishing town where the candidate lives. Alaskans also vote Tuesday on whether to scrap ranked-choice voting. What remains open is whether the Justice Department appeals, and how the two Sullivans split the vote before certification of the result.