On Monday, Nov. 2, Justice Department lawyers filed an emergency application at the Supreme Court. It asks the justices to order California to separate about 20,000 mail-in ballots from voters the department says are likely noncitizens. Lower courts have turned down the department's earlier requests, and judges who reviewed its list have questioned the evidence behind it. The department is also appealing the dismissal of its lawsuit over Alaska's Senate election. The 20,000 figure is the department's own count.
California counts mail ballots over several days, so an order from the Court could change what is counted after Election Day. Noncitizens cannot lawfully vote in federal elections, so the real question is whether the department's list actually identifies them, and judges have questioned the evidence. Emergency applications skip the normal appeals timetable, which is why the request lands on the night before the vote.
If you vote in California, your ballot is counted under state rules unless a court orders otherwise, and no such order exists now. Everywhere else, the filing shows how late legal fights can shape confidence in results. County election offices run ballot-tracking tools if you want to confirm yours was received.
The administration’s view is that election officials should not count ballots from people who are not citizens, and that waiting for lower courts to finish would let those ballots be counted before a ruling matters. It argues the stakes justify the Court acting immediately.
Judges who have turned the department down have questioned the evidence behind its list. Opponents of the request argue that eligible citizens could be wrongly swept in and that setting ballots aside days before the vote would disrupt the count without enough proof.
Confirmed: the application was filed, and the lower courts so far have not granted the department's requests. Not confirmed: that the 20,000 are noncitizens, which is the department's claim, and whether the Court will act before polls close Tuesday. Watch for an order from the justice who handles emergency matters for the 9th Circuit, or a referral to the full Court.
NPR (DOJ asks Supreme Court to intervene on California ballot demands, 11/2) · Los Angeles Times (Trump lawyers ask Supreme Court to set aside 20,000 ballots, 11/2) · CBS News (administration asks Court to intervene, 11/2) · The New York Times (emergency application on California ballots, 11/2)
Justice Department asks the Supreme Court to order California to set aside 20,000 mail ballots the night before Election DayJustice Department asks the Supreme Court to order California to set aside 20,000 mail ballots the night before Election Day
The emergency application, filed Monday, targets ballots the Justice Department says belong to likely noncitizens. Lower courts have already turned the department down.
The Trump administration on Monday asked the Supreme Court to step into a fight over 20,000 California mail-in ballots, one day before Election Day. In an emergency application, an urgent filing that skips the normal appeals timetable, Justice Department lawyers asked the justices to order California to separate the ballots of voters the department says are likely noncitizens. Lower courts have already turned the department down, and judges who reviewed its list have questioned the evidence behind it. California keeps counting mail ballots for days after Election Day, so the timing matters: an order from the Court would reach ballots that are still being processed.
The filing arrives alongside a second appeal. The department is also challenging the dismissal of its lawsuit over Alaska's Senate election, which a federal judge threw out on Sunday. Together the two cases put the courts at the center of the final hours of the midterm election. The 20,000 figure is the department's own count of voters it considers suspect; it is the department's claim, not a finding by any court. An emergency application goes first to the justice who handles urgent matters for the circuit involved, who can rule alone or refer it to the full Court. What is not known is whether the justices will act before polls begin closing Tuesday evening, or whether they would order any change in how California counts. No ruling from the Court had been announced by Monday evening.