Gov. Gavin Newsom announced on Thursday, Nov. 5, that he is commuting the death sentences of all 548 people on California's death row to life in prison without the possibility of parole. A commutation reduces a punishment and leaves the conviction in place. Newsom said that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with the values of California. The 548 sentences are about a quarter of all death sentences in the United States. The order does not repeal the state's death penalty and does not stop prosecutors from seeking death sentences in future cases. Newsom's term ends in January 2027. Defense attorney Mark Geragos said the decision is impossible to view outside a political lens.
A commutation is a final executive act for the sentences it covers, which is why the timing, in Newsom's last weeks in office, matters: a future governor cannot carry out these executions. California has held the nation's largest death row, so the order changes the national count of condemned prisoners at a stroke. It also leaves the law itself untouched, so the question of capital punishment in the state remains open for new cases.
If you live in California, little changes in what the state does day to day, because executions have been on hold. The practical effect falls on the prisoners, who move to a life sentence, and on victims' families, who no longer face a possible execution date. If you are a voter, the order shows how much of this issue rests with one elected official.
Newsom's own statement frames the death penalty as morally unacceptable. People who share that view add that an execution cannot be corrected if a conviction later proves mistaken, and they see the order as removing that risk for 548 people.
Geragos said the move cannot be separated from politics. People who favor capital punishment hold that sentences handed down by juries and upheld by courts should stand, a view the order sets aside in all 548 cases, including for families who waited years for a result.
Confirmed: the figure of 548, the shift to life without parole, and that the death penalty remains in state law. Not confirmed: whether prosecutors or victims' families will go to court, and how the prisoners will be housed. Watch for lawsuits and for statements from county prosecutors.
NBC News (Newsom commutes all death sentences, Nov 5) · New York Times (548 death row inmates, Nov 5) · Los Angeles Times (what the order does not do, Nov 5) · The Hill (Geragos comment, Nov 5)
Newsom Commutes the Sentences of All 548 People on California's Death Row to Life Without ParoleNewsom Commutes the Sentences of All 548 People on California's Death Row to Life Without Parole
The governor says state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California's values. The order does not repeal the death penalty, and prosecutors can still seek it in new cases.
Gov. Gavin Newsom announced on Thursday, Nov. 5, that he is commuting the death sentences of all 548 people on California's death row to life in prison without the possibility of parole. A commutation is a governor's order that lowers a punishment without erasing the conviction, so none of the 548 is cleared of the crime; each is to remain in prison for life. Newsom said that "state-sanctioned killing" is incompatible with the values of California, the most populous state. The 548 sentences amount to roughly a quarter of all death sentences in the country, so a single order changed the status of a very large share of the nation's condemned prisoners. The decision comes in the closing weeks of his time in office, which ends in January 2027, and it means a future governor cannot carry out these executions.
The order does not abolish the death penalty in California, and prosecutors can still ask for death sentences in future cases. Executions in the state have been on hold under a moratorium, a formal pause, that Newsom ordered earlier in his term, so the practical change is that the pause becomes permanent for these 548 prisoners. Life without parole means there is no hearing at which release could be considered. Defense attorney Mark Geragos, speaking on a cable news program, said the move is "impossible to view outside a political lens." It is not yet known how prosecutors, victims' families or the courts will respond, whether anyone will file a legal challenge, or when and how the prisoners will be moved out of death row housing.