On the 29th, at the closing hearing of the appellate trial before Criminal Division 12-1 of the Seoul High Court, the insurrection special counsel sought the death penalty for former President Yoon Suk Yeol on the charge of leading an insurrection. The special counsel said there was no reason to hesitate over a death sentence. The first-instance court, Criminal Collegiate Division 25 of the Seoul Central District Court, sentenced Yoon to life imprisonment on Feb. 19. Life imprisonment was sought for former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun and 30 years for Noh Sang-won, former commander of the Defense Intelligence Command, while 20 years was sought for former National Police Agency chief Cho Ji-ho and 15 years for former Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency chief Kim Bong-sik. Yoon’s side continues to deny the charges on appeal, and the defense team criticized the request as the true face of a political special counsel. The court said it will hold the final arguments and final statements at the hearing on the 3rd of next month and then announce the verdict date.
A sentencing request is only the sentence the prosecutor asks for; it is the court that sets the sentence. Whether the first-instance life imprisonment stands or changes to a death sentence at the appellate verdict will change the weight of the whole martial-law-related trial. That judgment also becomes a yardstick for gauging the sentences of the military and police leaders indicted over the same martial law.
Daily life does not change right away, but once the verdict date is set it is big news that could affect the political calendar and market mood. Until the verdict, it is enough to keep the requested sentence separate from the ruling.
The special counsel’s side holds that the martial law was prepared meticulously over a considerable period and that responsibility is not reduced because the people stopped it. It argues the first-instance life imprisonment is light given the gravity of the case.
Yoon’s side denies the insurrection charge itself and rebuts that the special counsel’s investigation and sentencing request are political. It wants the facts to be argued again on appeal.
What is confirmed is the death-penalty request and the Nov. 3 schedule for final arguments. What is not confirmed is the verdict date and result. Watch when the court says at the hearing on the 3rd that it will deliver the verdict.
Yonhap (breaking news on the sentencing request, 10/29) · Kyunghyang Shinmun (reasons for the request, 10/29) · Chosun Ilbo (appellate sentencing request, 10/29) · Dong-A Ilbo (death-penalty request, 10/29)
Insurrection ringleader Yoon Suk Yeol again faces a death-penalty request on appeal… life imprisonment sought for Kim Yong-hyun
At the Seoul High Court’s closing hearing the special counsel asked for the same sentence as at first instance. Final arguments come on the 3rd of next month, and the verdict date will be announced after that.
On the 29th the insurrection special counsel sought the death penalty for former President Yoon Suk Yeol at the closing hearing of the appellate trial before Criminal Division 12-1 of the Seoul High Court. Saying the life imprisonment handed down by the first-instance court on Feb. 19 was too light, the special counsel again asked for the death penalty it had sought at first instance and said there was no reason to hesitate over a death sentence. It also argued that an insurrection the people stopped is no ground for leniency. For former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun, who is being tried alongside Yoon, life imprisonment was sought; for Noh Sang-won, former commander of the Defense Intelligence Command, 30 years in prison; for former National Police Agency chief Cho Ji-ho, 20 years; and for former Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency chief Kim Bong-sik, 15 years. A closing hearing is the stage at which the evidence has been examined and the prosecutor states a view on the sentence. The special counsel has been asking the appellate court to accept the probative value of Noh Sang-won’s notebook, which the first-instance court did not recognize, as evidence that the martial law was prepared meticulously over a considerable period.
Yoon’s side continues to deny the insurrection charge on appeal, and the defense team rebutted the request as the true face of a political special counsel. The death penalty is the highest legal sentence, and this is the first time in 30 years, since former President Chun Doo-hwan in 1996, that a death sentence has been sought for a former president at first instance. Still, a sentencing request is not a verdict. At the hearing on the 3rd of next month the court will hear the defendants’ final arguments and final statements and then announce the date of the verdict, so that date is not yet set. With the trial over the Dec. 3 emergency martial law entering the closing stage of the appeal, what remains at issue is whether the first-instance life imprisonment will stand or change to a death sentence. The first-instance court sentenced Kim Yong-hyun to 30 years and Noh Sang-won to 18 years, and this time the special counsel raised its requests to life imprisonment and 30 years respectively.