Daegu Mayor Choo Kyung-ho was acquitted in a first-instance trial on the 18th. The charge is obstructing People Power Party lawmakers’ vote to lift martial law when emergency martial law was declared on December 3, 2024. Mayor Choo was then the People Power Party’s floor leader. The special counsel was reported to have made a sentencing request of 20 years. The court was reported to have judged that former President Yoon Suk Yeol’s request was not sufficiently proven, but details of the written ruling have not been confirmed. Right after the ruling, the People Power Party said it would consider filing a complaint against the special counsel for the crime of distorting the law. Former leader Han Dong-hoon was reported to have welcomed the result, and Democratic Party leader Jung Chung-rae was reported to have called for the impeachment of Chief Justice Cho Hee-de.
In trials related to the martial law case, evidence and the scope of what is proven differ from case to case, so outcomes can differ. This first-instance ruling shows that the issue was whether former President Yoon’s request was proven on the charge of ‘obstructing the vote’. A first-instance result is not final and may change on appeal.
The direct impact is small, but if the political dispute over the judiciary and the special counsel grows, it could affect upcoming trial schedules and the political landscape. When reading about a ruling, it helps to check both what an acquittal means and whether there will be an appeal.
This view holds that the special counsel’s investigation and indictment were excessive. The People Power Party and former leader Han Dong-hoon took the result as the natural consequence of the investigation and indictment, and even floated a complaint against the special counsel. This view treats the lack of proof as a problem with the indictment itself.
This view criticizes the ruling. On the Democratic Party side, responsibility of the judiciary was raised and a call to impeach the chief justice was made. This view holds that the first-instance judgment is not the final conclusion and should be examined again on appeal.
What is confirmed is the first-instance acquittal and the split reactions in politics. What is not confirmed is the detail of the court’s reasoning and whether the special counsel will appeal. Today, watch whether a position on appeal emerges and whether the People Power Party actually files a complaint.
Korea Economic Daily (first-trial acquittal flash, 11/18) · SBS (first-trial acquittal report, 11/18) · JoongAng Ilbo (first-trial acquittal flash, 11/18) · KBS (first-trial acquittal flash, 11/18) · Yonhap (People Power Party reaction, 11/18)
Politics · Courts✓ 5 outlets · details of the ruling’s reasoning and whether there will be an appeal unconfirmed
Choo Kyung-ho, accused of obstructing vote to lift martial law, acquitted in first trial
Ruling on the 18th… the court was reported to have found that former President Yoon’s request was not sufficiently proven
Daegu Mayor Choo Kyung-ho was found not guilty in a first-instance trial on the 18th. When emergency martial law was declared on December 3, 2024, Mayor Choo was the People Power Party’s floor leader, and was indicted on a charge of obstructing the People Power Party lawmakers’ vote to lift martial law. The special counsel was reported to have made a sentencing request of 20 years. The court was reported to have found that former President Yoon Suk Yeol’s request to Mayor Choo to block the vote was not sufficiently proven, but details of the reasoning have yet to be confirmed. In a criminal trial, an acquittal is a finding that the evidence to prove guilt is insufficient, and it may not mean that nothing of the kind happened at all.
Reactions in political circles split sharply right after the ruling. The People Power Party issued a position that “the insurrection hunt is over now” and said it would consider filing a complaint against the investigating special counsel for the crime of distorting the law. Han Dong-hoon, a former People Power Party leader, was reported to have said the result was the natural consequence of the special counsel’s excessive investigation and indictment. Democratic Party leader Jung Chung-rae was reported to have argued that Chief Justice Cho Hee-de should be impeached. Whether the special counsel will appeal is not yet known; the deadline to appeal is seven days from the day after the ruling.
Unfold the story and DailyDrop’s take
President Lee Jae-myung held a summit with President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, China, on the 18th. The talks were reported to have lasted about 34 minutes. Cheong Wa Dae said President Xi expressed support for efforts to ease tensions on the Korean Peninsula, including U.S.-North Korea dialogue. President Lee was reported to have asked China for a constructive role on Korean Peninsula issues and to have said the two sides should work together toward a fundamental solution to the Yellow Sea issue. President Xi was reported to have said China and South Korea should uphold strategic autonomy and contribute to regional peace and development. The follow-up Korea-China FTA services and investment negotiations were substantially concluded that day, and the two leaders agreed to expand cooperation on the back of it.
On the Korean Peninsula situation, China has deep ties with North Korea and is a counterpart the South Korean government must persuade to help resume dialogue. Conclusion of the FTA services and investment talks could change the conditions for entering service sectors such as content, tourism and finance, so the economic impact is large. Whether the hallyu ban is actually lifted depends on follow-up steps by the two governments.
If you work in content, tourism or services, the conditions for entering the Chinese market may change. There is no change consumers will feel right away, but if Korea-China relations thaw, tourism and exchanges could grow.
This is the security and diplomacy view. It sees China’s remarks of support for easing tensions on the peninsula and the explanation of North Korea-China developments as clues to resuming dialogue. This view also treats it as meaningful that the Yellow Sea issue was raised directly at the summit.
This is the economic view. It expects the conclusion of the services and investment talks to open the content market and expand co-production. But since there is no official announcement on lifting the hallyu ban, it holds that actual change has to be checked.
What is confirmed is that the summit took place, that the FTA services and investment talks were concluded, and President Xi’s remarks as relayed by Cheong Wa Dae. What is not confirmed is the agreement documents and the timing of any lifting of the hallyu ban. Today, watch whether the two countries release details of the agreement and the signing schedule.
Yonhap (leaders’ remarks and FTA conclusion, 11/18) · Kyunghyang Shinmun (Xi Jinping’s remarks on the Korean Peninsula, 11/18) · Dong-A Ilbo (Cheong Wa Dae briefing, 11/18) · Electronic Times (emphasis on economic cooperation, 11/18)
Diplomacy · Korea-China✓ 4 outlets · agreement documents and whether the hallyu ban will be lifted unconfirmed
President Lee holds summit with Xi Jinping in Shenzhen… cooperation to expand after conclusion of FTA services and investment talks
President Lee Jae-myung held a summit with President Xi Jinping on the 18th, on the occasion of attending the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China. It was the two leaders’ third meeting, and the talks were reported to have lasted about 34 minutes. Cheong Wa Dae said President Xi expressed support for various efforts to ease tensions on the Korean Peninsula, including U.S.-North Korea dialogue, and also explained developments in North Korea-China relations to President Lee. President Lee was reported to have asked China to play a constructive role in resolving Korean Peninsula issues and to have said the two sides should work together toward a fundamental solution to the Yellow Sea issue. President Xi was reported to have said China and South Korea should uphold strategic autonomy and contribute to regional peace and development. The economic backdrop is that the follow-up Korea-China FTA services and investment negotiations were substantially concluded on the 18th. The two leaders agreed to broaden cooperation on the back of this conclusion. Reports said the terms include most-favored-nation treatment in China’s content market and more co-production, and attention is on whether the hallyu ban in film and tourism will be lifted. The hallyu ban refers to informal measures by which China has restricted the distribution of Korean cultural content. No official announcement on whether or when it will be lifted has been confirmed, and details of the agreement text and the signing schedule are also not yet known.
Unfold the story and DailyDrop’s take