The Supreme Court's Grand Bench ruled on the 11th that the July 2025 House of Councillors election was in an “unconstitutional state” and rejected the claim seeking election invalidation. The disparity in the value of a vote between districts was up to 3.13 times. The presiding judge was Chief Justice Yukihiko Imazaki, and it was a final appeal judgment bringing together 16 lawsuits. The Grand Bench expressed the view that “the imbalance in the value of votes has reached a level that cannot be overlooked.” It is the first time in about 12 years that a House of Councillors election has been found in an unconstitutional state, and the first since merged districts were introduced in 2016. At the high court stage, 11 of the 16 cases found an unconstitutional state and 5 found the election constitutional. The 2023 Supreme Court ruling on the 2022 election had called correcting the disparity an “urgent task.”
An unconstitutional state amounts to a warning from the Supreme Court urging the Diet to make corrections. Because the disparity widened to 3.13 times even after the 2023 ruling pointed to an “urgent task,” the question is whether the Diet's efforts were sufficient. The debate touches the very structure of the upper house: whether to add merged districts, revise the allocation of seats, or move on to constitutional revision.
This is a problem of one's own vote carrying different weight depending on where one lives, and it concerns every voter. If where one lives changes through a move or going to school, the value of one's vote can change too. Depending on whether the Diet acts before the next House of Councillors election, the framework of electoral districts could change.
Some see the ruling as sending a strong message to the Diet. A professor at Senshu University points out that the state has not taken sufficient measures so far. The reading is that it presses a Diet that has put off corrections to make concrete revisions.
The parties' positions on how to correct it are far apart. From those who value the upper house's distinctiveness and prefecture-based representation come cautious voices about expanding merged districts. Others say merged districts have their limits and look for a different framework, so the debate tends to stall.
What we could confirm is the finding of an unconstitutional state and the rejection of the claim for election invalidation. What to watch next is whether the parties put forward concrete plans to revise merged districts or the allocation of seats, and whether the Diet sets up a forum for deliberation. The full text of the ruling and individual justices' opinions have not been confirmed.
NHK (Supreme Court Grand Bench ruling, 11/11) · Mainichi Shimbun (ruling and parties' reactions, 11/11) · Jiji Press (ruling, 11/11)
Politics · JudiciaryPress ✓ 3 outlets · full ruling and each justice's opinion unconfirmed
Supreme Court Grand Bench Finds Last July's Upper House Election in “Unconstitutional State”; Disparity of Up to 3.13 Times, Claim to Invalidate Election Rejected
First ruling since merged districts were introduced, and the first on an upper house election in about 12 years. The Diet is now pressed to revisit the electoral system.
The Supreme Court's Grand Bench ruled on the 11th that the July 2025 House of Councillors election, in which the disparity in the value of a vote had widened to as much as 3.13 times, was in an “unconstitutional state” contrary to equality in the value of votes. However, it rejected the claim seeking election invalidation, so the victories themselves remain valid. The ruling was a final appeal judgment handling 16 lawsuits together, and Chief Justice Yukihiko Imazaki presided. The Grand Bench expressed the view that “the imbalance in the value of votes has reached a level that cannot be overlooked.” The “vote-value disparity” is a ratio showing how much the weight of one vote differs between a district with fewer voters and one with more; at 3.13 times, one vote in a given district carries only about a third of the weight of a vote in another district.
An “unconstitutional state” is a ruling that the situation violates the equality the Constitution demands but has not yet exceeded the grace period the Diet has to correct it, so it stops short of the kind of unconstitutionality that would invalidate an election. It is the first such ruling on a House of Councillors election in about 12 years, and the first since 2016, when “merged districts” were introduced, combining neighboring prefectures such as Tottori and Shimane, and Tokushima and Kochi, into a single electoral district. At the high court stage, opinions had split, with 11 of the 16 cases finding an unconstitutional state and 5 finding the election constitutional. The 2023 Supreme Court ruling on the 2022 election also called correcting the disparity an “urgent task.” The parties differ sharply on how to correct it, and some point out that merged districts have their limits. The Diet's concrete response to the ruling has not yet been decided.
Open the story and DailyDrop's take
Multiple reports on the 11th said the government is studying a plan to write an emergency exception into the “no introduction” principle of the Three Non-Nuclear Principles in revising the three security documents. The sources are senior administration and government officials, and it is not an official government announcement. The three documents are scheduled to be revised within the year. The Okada reply is what Foreign Minister Katsuya Okada said in the Diet in 2010: that where Japan's safety could not be protected without allowing temporary port calls by nuclear weapons, the government would make the judgment. Successive governments have carried this position over, and Prime Minister Takaichi has also declared that the position will be carried over. A senior government official reportedly said, “Is it right to keep calling it the Okada reply forever?” The final decision is expected to come after discussion among the ruling parties and experts.
The Three Non-Nuclear Principles have been regarded as the foundation of postwar Japan's security. If the exception is written into the document, an interpretation that had been confined to a Diet reply would be elevated to an official government document. It also bears on the direction of security policy as a whole, including how to position the nuclear deterrent of an ally.
Whether the wording of the principles changes goes straight to the question of what kind of country Japan is in its dealings with nuclear weapons. How port calls and introduction are handled could also affect daily life in regions with ports and bases. It is a report of a study stage, not a decision, and that point deserves attention.
Those seeking a review believe that options for emergencies should be kept in order to preserve the effectiveness of the US nuclear deterrent. Prime Minister Takaichi is said to have shown views to this effect since before taking office. The aim is said to be removing ambiguity by putting the reply into a document.
Atomic bomb survivors and the heads of bombed cities have called for upholding the principles. There is persistent concern that writing in an exception would gradually dilute them. Atomic bomb survivors have voiced criticism that the horror of nuclear weapons is not understood.
What we could confirm is only that multiple reports say the idea is being studied within the administration; the government has not decided. What to watch next is whether a draft of the document is made public and what wording emerges from discussion among the ruling parties and experts. It is too early to take this as “abolition.”
Asahi Shimbun (study of writing in an exception, 11/11) · TV Asahi ANN (plan for emergency exception, 11/11) · FNN (studied in revising the three security documents, 11/11)
Security · PoliticsPress ✓ 3 outlets · not a formal government decision; source is senior administration officials
Government Studying Plan to Write Emergency Exception Into “No Introduction” Principle of Three Non-Nuclear Principles in Revising Security Documents, Officials Say; Not a Formal Decision
The government is studying a plan to write an emergency exception into the “no introduction” principle of the Three Non-Nuclear Principles in revising the three security-related documents (the three security documents), which it plans to revise within the year, multiple reports revealed on the 11th. The reports were attributed to senior administration officials, and the government has not made an official announcement. The Three Non-Nuclear Principles are the national policy of “not possessing, not producing and not allowing the introduction of nuclear weapons,” and the current National Security Strategy says it will “uphold” them. The plan is said to keep the principles themselves while writing into the document room for an exception allowing nuclear weapons to be brought in during an emergency. Behind it lies the reply that then Foreign Minister Katsuya Okada gave in the Diet in 2010 (the Okada reply). It held that in an emergency in which Japan's safety could not be protected without allowing a temporary port call by a ship carrying nuclear weapons, the government of the day would make a political judgment; successive governments have carried this position over, and Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi has likewise declared that the position will be carried over. A senior government official reportedly said, “Is it right to keep calling it the Okada reply forever?” and indicated a wish to incorporate wording of the Takaichi government's own. The prime minister told the House of Representatives Budget Committee in October that there is “room for consideration” in the wording. In response, atomic bomb survivors have voiced criticism that the horror of nuclear weapons is not understood. The content of the document has not yet been settled.
Open the story and DailyDrop's take