On the 18th, the Grand Bench of the Supreme Court ruled “constitutional” on the provision of the Public Offices Election Act that denies the vote across the board to inmates serving sentences, holding that it does not violate the Constitution, which guarantees the right to vote. It is the first time the Supreme Court has ruled in a case contesting whether this provision violates the Constitution. The Grand Bench is a court in which all 15 justices of the Supreme Court sit together. The detailed reasoning and the breakdown of the justices' opinions have not been confirmed.
The right to vote is a basic right of political participation that the Constitution guarantees to the people. Whether that right can be restricted by law for some people is judged by whether the restriction has a reasonable basis. The Supreme Court's ruling becomes the premise for similar lawsuits and for debate in the Diet.
The relationship between being convicted and serving a sentence in a criminal case and holding the right to vote is not something people usually think about. It is worth knowing that, with this ruling, the current treatment, under which people cannot vote while serving a sentence, will continue for the time being. The right to vote after release is a separate matter.
One view holds that the right to vote is a basic right of the people even for prisoners, and that restrictions should be kept to a minimum. This position considers that depriving people of the chance to vote can also hinder their return to society.
One view holds that some rights may unavoidably be restricted while a punishment is being served, and that a uniform rule is fair. This position considers that a clear line is needed to keep elections fair.
What has been confirmed is limited to the Grand Bench's ruling of constitutional and the fact that this is its first ruling on the provision. The details of the reasoning and how the justices' opinions were divided have not been confirmed. Once the text of the judgment is published, we want to check what it was based on.
NHK (Restriction on prisoners' voting rights is constitutional, 11/18) · Asahi Shimbun (Denying prisoners the vote is constitutional, 11/18) · Mainichi Shimbun (Election law provision is constitutional, 11/18)
Law Denying Prisoners the Vote Is “Constitutional,” Supreme Court Grand Bench Rules in First Decision
The Supreme Court's Grand Bench has issued its first ruling that the provision of the Public Offices Election Act denying the vote across the board to inmates serving sentences does not violate the Constitution.
On the 18th, the Grand Bench of the Supreme Court ruled that the provision of the Public Offices Election Act that denies the vote across the board to inmates serving sentences is “constitutional,” holding that it does not violate the Constitution, which guarantees the right to vote. It is the first time the Supreme Court has ruled in a case contesting whether this provision violates the Constitution. The Grand Bench is a court in which all 15 justices of the Supreme Court sit together, convened for weighty cases such as constitutional rulings and changes to past precedents. A ruling of constitutional means that the court recognizes a legal provision as not contrary to the Constitution.
At issue was the system under which no one can vote while serving a sentence in a prison or similar facility. With this ruling, the Supreme Court has treated the provision as valid. However, the detailed reasoning behind the conclusion that it is constitutional, and whether the justices were divided in their opinions, cannot be confirmed in current reports. Had the provision been struck down, the question would have been whether the Diet would revise the law, but that did not happen. Whether debate over the provision will continue in the Diet and elsewhere is also not yet known.