U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman of Alaska confirmed Friday that a civil investigation and a criminal investigation are both ongoing into an alleged scheme to put a second Dan Sullivan on the state's Senate ballot. The allegation is that Democrats recruited independent candidate Daniel J. Sullivan, whose name is nearly identical to that of Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, to confuse voters. Heyman said the criminal inquiry has run for months, declined to name targets or possible charges, and said he is not assuming a crime occurred. The Justice Department asked a federal judge for a preliminary injunction directing Alaska to preserve and segregate ballots that rank Daniel J. Sullivan, and asked for a decision by Monday. Alaska calls the suit meritless, says separating ballots would break ballot secrecy, and says it keeps ballots for 22 months. Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered a state investigation. Mary Peltola, the Democratic nominee, says she knew nothing about any candidate other than herself and the incumbent.
Federal prosecutors rarely take visible steps in an election matter this close to voting, because Justice Department practice has long counseled caution about actions that could affect a race. The court request matters because it would change how Alaska handles ballots before counting, which is where a close Senate race is decided. Whether name confusion is a crime, a civil violation or lawful if distasteful politics will decide whether the probe goes anywhere.
If you vote in Alaska, your ballot is affected only if you ranked Daniel J. Sullivan, and the state says it cannot pull ballots aside without breaking secrecy. Anywhere else, expect this fight to color arguments over whether the federal government is policing or influencing the midterms, and watch for the Monday deadline the department set.
Supporters of the investigation say a same-name candidate recruited to siphon votes is exactly the kind of deception election law exists to stop, and that preserving ballots costs little compared with losing evidence. On this view, acting before votes are counted is the point of the request.
Critics, including Democrats and Alaska's own officials, say a criminal inquiry and a court filing days before the election amount to federal interference, that no crime has been identified, and that setting ballots apart would compromise secrecy for voters who did nothing wrong.
Confirmed: both investigations exist, the court filing exists, and the state opposes it. Not confirmed: who is a target, what law is at issue, which judge will rule and whether any ballots will be separated. Watch the Monday deadline and whether the court acts before Tuesday.
PBS NewsHour (criminal probe confirmed, Oct. 30) · NBC News (ballot separation request, Oct. 30) · CBS News (Justice Department calls allegations troubling, Oct. 30) · The Hill (probe of alleged spoiler scheme, Oct. 30)
Alaska's top federal prosecutor confirms criminal investigation of Senate ballot scheme as Justice Department asks court to separate ballotsAlaska's top federal prosecutor confirms criminal investigation of Senate ballot scheme as Justice Department asks court to separate ballots
U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman declined to name targets or charges, and Alaska says setting ballots apart would break ballot secrecy.
The top federal prosecutor in Alaska confirmed Friday that a criminal investigation is under way into an alleged scheme to put a second Dan Sullivan on the state's Senate ballot. U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman said, "There is both a civil investigation and a criminal investigation that is ongoing," and that the criminal inquiry has run for months. The allegation is that Democrats recruited an independent named Daniel J. Sullivan, whose name is nearly identical to that of the Republican incumbent, Sen. Dan Sullivan, to confuse voters and pull votes away from him. Heyman declined to say who the targets are, what charges could follow or which law is at issue, and said he is not assuming a crime was committed. Mary Peltola, the Democratic nominee, has said she knew nothing about any candidate on the ballot other than herself and the incumbent.
The Justice Department also asked a federal judge Friday for a preliminary injunction, an early court order issued before a case is decided, directing Alaska to preserve and segregate ballots on which voters rank Daniel J. Sullivan. It asked for a decision on the separation request by Monday, one day before Election Day. Alaska opposes the request and calls the lawsuit meritless. The state says ballots are mixed together on Election Day, so pulling some aside would break ballot secrecy, and that it already keeps ballots for 22 months. Gov. Mike Dunleavy has ordered a state investigation. Democrats have condemned the civil suit and the criminal investigation as an effort to influence the outcome. No ruling on the request has been announced.